Optimization Theories of the Transition from Foraging to Agriculture: A Critical Assessment and Proposed Alternatives
Journal Title: Social Evolution & History - Year 2017, Vol 16, Issue 1
Abstract
es, one in economics and the other in anthropology, explain the economic evolution of Neolithic societies, particularly their transit from foraging to agriculture. Both assume rational optimizing behavior. It is argued that satisficing theories provide a superior explanation of transition (and non-transition) by some huntergatherers. Furthermore, many of the concepts associated with neoclassical economics are shown to be inadequate for analyzing the choice problems involved. Moreover, it is argued that all behavioral theories considering the relationship between human behavior and economic evolution need to pay attention to the way that decision-making is embedded in social structures. It is unlikely that a single theory will be able to explain the economic evolution of all societies when social structures and other relevant variables differ between communities.
Authors and Affiliations
Clem Tisdell, Serge Svizzero
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP265907
- DOI -
- Views 151
- Downloads 0
Florovsky at the Crossroads: Imagining Byzantine Renaissance from Morningside Heights
Georges Florovsky, an influential theologian, came to New York City in 1948 to be dean of the Russian St Vladimir Theological Seminary. At Morningside Heights, Florovsky taught about what went wrong in Russia in 1917 and...
The Surprise that Transforms. An American Perspective on What the 2040s Might Bring
Each long wave peak has been followed by a cluster of paradigm-shifting innovations that transform every aspect of work and life. We expect that the next peak of c. 2036 will also be followed by a decade-long cluster o...
The Explanatory Potential of Rational Choice Theory: A Critical Assessment
What are the explanatory values characteristic of concepts considering humans as entities aimed at maximizing expected utility by means of coherent and logical decisions? Do citizens who are active in politics behave acc...
Matriliny in Evolutionary Priority
While dismissing the nineteenth century theory of matrilineal priority as an evolutionary scenario, George Murdock (1937) finds that the theory would seem to have validity, provided that one assumes (and he does not) evo...
The Odyssey of Michel Izard: An Appreciation
In the French academic system there have been two kinds of doctoral degrees. The first, Le Doctorat 3-ème cycle, is fairly common and can be compared roughly to doctoral degrees in the United States, the UK and elsewhere...