Other and Stranger in the structure of the human self (Buber, Levinas, Kristeva)
Journal Title: Наукові записки НаУКМА. Філософія та релігієзнавство - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
In this article, the author examines the relationship between the human self and its two distinctive conditions – the Other, as any alternative form of being, and the Stranger, as hostility. In the first part of the article, the author shows historical and cultural dimensions of Self and the Other in the European context. In this regard, anything that does not belong to a particular cultural area is deprived of ontological status and expelled. The Other has attributes of femininity or bestiality and is associated with evil or deviation. However, the extraordinariness of the Other causes a certain enchantment. Finally, the Other becomes an image of the mirror that offers a look at oneself from aside. The second part exposes the structure of the relationship between Me and Thou according to the theory of Martin Buber (1878–1965). Here the monolithic world appears as a double. Openness, intimacy, and trust are characteristic for this construction. Aggressive forms of power are replaced with respect and responsibility. In the third part, based on the ideas of Emmanuel Levinas (1906–1995), the totality of being is proved unlocked by interaction with the Other. It becomes possible as a response to sympathy and love. Therefore, the Other is revealed through his/her face that one can see, while human condition is based on the fact that a human cares for the existence of the Other. Finally, in the fourth part, the author appeals to Julia Kristeva (born 1941) approach to the problem of Stranger. He finds out that the possibility of recognizing the essential elements of Stranger within our Self is an important aspect of human identity, as we will only be able to clarify our own purposes by accepting someone else in ourselves.
Authors and Affiliations
Тaras Lyuty
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP486291
- DOI 10.18523/2617-16781141914
- Views 42
- Downloads 0
Aristotle’s doctrine of substance: Thomistic view
The article considers one of the most significant concepts in Aristotelian philosophy: the concept of substance and its interpretation in the works of existential Thomists. The emphasis is placed on the fact that the doc...
Утопія і нігілізм: філософські уроки Лєшека Колаковського
У статті проаналізовано основні аспекти тлумачення філософського мислення польським філософом Лєшеком Колаковським (1927–2009) тією мірою, якою вони пов’язані з питанням автономності мислення. Метою є реконструкція принц...
Manuscript “Neoplatonic Philosophy” by Pamfil D. Yurkevych: source criticism
This article is the first to bring into scientific discussion and to provide a historico-philosophical analysis of a manuscript “Neoplatonic Philosophy from the archive of Pamfil Danylovych Yurkevych (1826–1874). The rev...
Становлення великих груп: від натовпу та публіки до владно-видовищних масових рухів
У статті розглянуто підходи до масових рухів у історичному процесі та їхній вплив на стан західної культури. Продемонстровано перехід від психології натовпу до структури масового інстинкту та колективної взаємодії. Висві...
How to read author: meditation on method
Based on the reception of Emmanuel Levinas (1906–1995) philosophy in the English-speaking world, the paper highlights some tendencies in reading and commenting on classical philosophical works that have been the focus of...