Outsourcing of production: the valuation of volume flexibiltiy in decision-making
Journal Title: LogForum - Year 2018, Vol 14, Issue 1
Abstract
Background: Outsourcing remains a central mechanism for improving manufacturing supply chains, with volume flexibility being a frequently targeted objective. However, outsourcing decision-making remains focused on static cost estimations, while the value of volume flexibility is subject to managerial valuation, thus imposing a risk of estimation errors. This paper tests whether decision-makers systematically under- or overvalue volume flexibility when deciding on outsourcing. Methods: Four outsourcing decision made by an OEM operating with seasonality and boom and bust cycles are analyzed to assess if decision-makers’ intrinsic valuation of volume flexibility is biased. This was done by utilizing a previously developed mixed integer linear programming model for tactical planning. The model jointly considers production planning, workforce adjustments and capital investment, while respecting upstream supplier constraints, thereby encompassing both positive and negative effects of production outsourcing on volume flexibility. Combining the model with detailed knowledge of how the production system would be impacted, enabled a quantification of the value from volume flexibility, which could then be compared to the decisions made. Results: Augmenting existing static cost estimations with the value of flexibility did not reveal systematic estimation errors. However, the results suggest that the value of volume flexibility is situational, and on average comparable to direct labor cost. Conclusions: The results emphasize the importance of accurately and case-specific valuation of volume flexibility in cost-driven production outsourcing.
Authors and Affiliations
Jesper N. Asmussen, Jesper Kristensen, Brian V. Wæhrens
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP508275
- DOI 10.17270/J.LOG.2018.263
- Views 147
- Downloads 0
Comparison of time-oriented methods to check manufacturing activities and an examination of their efficiency
Background: Warehouse Production management systems now require IT aspects which can be automated, so that processes can be easily reviewed. During our research, we analyzed four and a half years of database and...
Drivers of green supply chain management
Background: In the manufacturing business, producers have been facing the problem to decrease the environmental effects during the manufacturing procedure. There is a need for the dedication and resources to address t...
Product lifecycle management framework for business transformation
Background: The role of Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) in business change varies in scope and impact. PLM initiatives range from Information System (IS) change to strategic business transformation, and capabilitie...
The efficiency of products classification methods and classification criteria
Introduction: It is shown in this paper, presented selected aspects of the impact that the distribution of products in a warehouse has on the picking of orders. This problem is particularly important for medium a...
Designing reverse logistics network in an omni-channel environment in Asia
Background: Omni-channel retailers have been growing globally to connect with customers anywhere and thus blurring the line between online web store and the physical store to deliver a seamless customer experience. Th...