Progressive Legal Perspective on the Ultra Petita Decision of the Constitutional Court
Journal Title: International Journal of Social Science And Human Research - Year 2023, Vol 6, Issue 01
Abstract
Until now, the discourse on ultra petita decisions has not found a point meeting between various parties. In this matter it is also necessary to examine, what are the considerations for making ultra decisions the petita , so that it can be known in what ways the constitutional judges can drop decision which contain super petita. From consideration- With these considerations, we can determine whether there really is enforcement law which progressive. This legal research uses a normative juridical approach with research specification analytical description. The type of data used is secondary data, consists of primary legal materials, secondary legal materials and tertiary legal materials. Technique data collection using library research ( library research) and from the data which collected and then analyzed in a manner qualitative-normative. From results study which conducted get it conclusion, that doctrine ban super petita for judge no apply absolute and general. With use approach normative and interpretation systemic could said that provision in Constitution MK nor Regulation MK no give possibility for judge constitution for make decision super petita. In issue decisions containing ultra petita, in general the Court based there is an inseparable connection between the article being reviewed and other articles which is not tested, so therefore the article or the entire law must be stated no strength law, in side because reason for avoid lawlessness and uphold substantive justice. MK's breakthrough in making ultra petita decisions in principle are a form of progressive law enforcement, However, any creativity carried out by law enforcers may not be progressive meaning if not to realize substantive justice, placing justice, benefit and human happiness as a goal finally.
Authors and Affiliations
Alvin Afriansyah , Joko Setiyono
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP712478
- DOI 10.47191/ijsshr/v6-i1-71
- Views 56
- Downloads 0
The Influence of Capital, Food Costs, and Use of Labor on Production and Income of Broiler Chicken Farmers in the Tabanan District, Bali
This research is motivated by the development of broiler chicken farming businesses in the Bali province. This is influenced by the level of demand for the production of meat, eggs and broiler chicken seeds which is incr...
Analysis of Factors Affecting the Income of Female Flower Traders in the Market Wangaya Flower Denpasar
Female's current involvement in the business sector is caused by economic uncertainty, rising prices, basic needs, and stagnation of family income. This phenomenon is the reason why women decide to work in the informal s...
Implementing Legislation A Priory Assertion to Rule of Law in Bangladesh
The constitution of Bangladesh contains a plethora of laws to maintain peace and security in the society through establishing the rule of law. The judiciary of the country is independent since 2007 but to some extent, th...
The Influence of Modernity, Lifestyle and Economic Literacy on the Consumptive Behavior of Economics Education Students at Universitas Negeri Gorontalo
People's consumption choices no longer reflect their ability to distinguish between urgent needs and less important wants. Consumption patterns can be recognized by cues evident in an individual's purchasing habits, like...
Optimizing Human Resource Management to Enhance Productivity and Economic Competitiveness in the Era of Industry 4.0
In the context of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, human resource management involves effective administration and the optimization of human resources to meet new productivity and economic competition demands. This pape...