Prudential Versus Probative Arguments for Religious Faith: Descartes and Pascal on Reason and Faith
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2017, Vol 8, Issue 8
Abstract
In this article, I show that Pascal’s prudential agenda, centered on the Wager, more successfully overcomes the restrictions of Pyrrhonic skepticism expressed by Montaigne than Descartes’ probative philosophy, which was based on his “ontological argument” for God’s existence. Descartes’ attempt to base natural science on the metaphysical certainty of a non-deceiving God fails because he cannot prove that a non-deceiving Perfect Being is a “clear and distinct” idea. Pascal’s attempt to base the knowledge of God upon the “reasons of the heart” accepts the epistemological restrictions of skepticism but provides a reason to develop passionate faith, thereby overcoming skepticism. I also show that Descartes and Pascal had different assumptions about the workings of the mind; Descartes relied on a model of the mind as a “theater,” which hindered his agenda, and Pascal upon a “holistic” model, which enabled him to make a prudential argument which was cognitively convincing.
Authors and Affiliations
Dennis Sansom
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25731
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel8080136
- Views 273
- Downloads 9
Nurses’ Understanding of Spirituality and the Spirituality of Older People with Dementia in the Continuing Care Setting
This research paper was presented at the Third International Spirituality in Healthcare Conference 2017—‘Creating Space for Spirituality in Healthcare’ at Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin. 22 June 2017....
Abelard: Celebrity and Charisma—A Response to Dickson
One might think that Peter Abelard (1079?–1144?) would be the best example of a medieval charismatic teacher. But his rival and prosecutor St Bernard of Clairvaux (1090?–1153) fits the criteria rather better. Unlike Be...
The Green Revolution in the World’s Religions: Indonesian Examples in International Comparison
Similar to progressive political movements, the programs of many religious and spiritual groups today are converging around a shared commitment to address the impending global ecological crisis. The paper explores this...
Erratum: Belief in Reincarnation and Some Unresolved Questions in Catholic Eschatology. Religions 2017, 8, 176
The editorial team of the journal Religions would like to make the following changes to the published paper (Malkovsky 2017): For note 20 the “pp.”, which appears three times, should be deleted. We apologize for any i...
Central European Jewish Émigrés and the Shaping of Postwar Culture: Studies in Memory of Lilian Furst (1931–2009)
This volume grew out of a conference on “Jewish Émigrés and the Shaping of Postwar Culture,” organized by the Triangle Intellectual History Seminar and the Duke-UNC Jewish Studies Seminar to commemorate the late Lilian...