Purely Consequentialist Legal Activism in the Brazilian Criminal Constitutional Jurisdiction based on Case Studies in the Jurisprudence of the Supreme Federal Court
Journal Title: Annals of Bioethics & Clinical Applications - Year 2021, Vol 4, Issue 3
Abstract
The present study intended, based on the use of the methodology related to legal consequentialism, the field of consequentialist argumentation and possible risks of its use by judges, in particular, those who perform constitutional jurisdiction and efficient speeches and the concept of purely consequentialist activism, assess whether, and to what extent, it would be possible to divide the concept of purely consequentialist activism into degrees according to the legal nature of the decision handed down within the scope of the Supreme Federal Court, more specifically, with regard to the (non) provisionality of the decision. Throughout the work it was possible to divide purely consequentialist activism into two species. The first of these, called first degree consequentialist activism, characterized by monocratic decisions or judgments that respect the limits of merit and, consequently, the principle of collegiality, and; second-degree consequentialist activism, characterized by monocratic decisions that, not meeting the limits of precautionary decisions, end up disrespecting the principle of collegiality.
Authors and Affiliations
Minervino Quintiere V*
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP745569
- DOI 10.23880/abca-16000195
- Views 52
- Downloads 0
The Internet and Cancellation Culture: The Impact of the Public Opinion on the Exercise of the Individual Right to Freedom of Expression
This article analyzes the impact of the culture of cancellation promoted by users of social networks on the exercise of individual rights, more precisely Freedom of Expression. The study presents the analysis of the cont...
The Exercise of the Law and the Need to Update, before Pandemia Problems 2019
In today’s times, it is necessary to think about updating for the modern professional exercise, using information technologies and strengthening in the future.
Medical Branch Choice in Turkey and Beneficience
Medical school trainings are provided to enable medical students to benefit their patients in their professional lives. When looking at occupational branch preferences, it is seen that the physicians are in a position to...
Ethics in the Immunization of the Cuban People against COVID-19
Covid-19 has raised multiple topics for reflection; among them is the problem of vaccination against such a pandemic. The article seeks to reveal that the Cuban strategy for immunizing the population against this epidemi...
Silence is the Language of God and Source of Strength: Exploring the Hidden Benefits of Silence
Silent is a beautiful powerful boost of positive energy and it is an important aspect of worship. Our mind is moving towards past and future. Bringing mindfulness into the present time during our materialistic society of...