Qualitative Exploration of the Social Context of the Tax Payment Process
Journal Title: Journal of Applied Sociology - Year 2022, Vol 33, Issue 3
Abstract
Introduction: As a source of government revenue for the provision of various social, welfare, and cultural services, taxes have a long history. With regard to their role in the economic and social developments of societies despite the lack of desirable and a voluntary tax payment behavior, it is necessary to identify the social contexts of tax payment so as to encourage trust and public participation in this process. Thus, this study aimed to explore the social contexts for tax payment behavior and identify the conditions and factors that play a role in increasing or decreasing public trust and participation in it. Materials & Methods: To meet the purpose of the research and achieve a deep understanding of the social context concerning this issue, an interpretive paradigm and qualitative approach was employed based on the grounded theory. The theoretical purposive sampling was used to select the participants. The financial managers of production companies in Yazd Province in Iran, who had lived experiences of the context and consented to participate in this research, were selected as the target community. 13 managers with different ages and work and management experiences participated in the study. The data obtained from the interviews were transcribed and analyzed as soon as they were collected so as to reveal the relevant ambiguous and sensitive points and obtain the final theory; thus, the researcher could pay more attention to them in the subsequent interviews. Sampling continued until the theoretical saturation was reached. At the open coding stage, the text was analyzed line by line (sometimes word by word) and the annotations and additional explanations were written as comments in the Microsoft Word file in the margins of the interview text and the attached concepts. In the next stage, the obtained concepts and subcategories were reduced to the main categories and the core category was constructed in relation to the main categories and subcategories obtained from the previous two stages based on a fixed comparison technique. Finally, to show the structure and process of the discovery and construction of the core category, a paradigm model was drawn up, which consisted of 5 sections: causal conditions, contextual conditions, intervening conditions, axial phenomenon, strategies, and consequences. Throughout the process, we adhered to the ethics and scientific principles by maintaining confidentiality of the information and using nicknames for the participants, besides observing other ethical considerations, such as participant’s consent and non-manipulation of data. Discussion of Results & Conclusions: The research findings indicated 29 main categories and one core category entitled "tax value inversion". Based on this paradigm model, the evidence from the participants' narratives and theoretical design of the research was presented. The research results demonstrated the formation of axial phenomenon called "tax evasion/compulsory taxation". In this way, the actors were faced by a situation that involved coercion and mutual distrust, especially institutional distrust. Accordingly, they were reluctant to pay taxes and even avoided paying them. They made various justifications and excuses to legitimize their tax evasion, resulting in the reduced amount of the paid taxes. However, once they failed in their tax evasion, they were forced by the tax officers to pay them. In general, it could be said that a number of micro and especially macro factors played a role in directing either a voluntary or evasive tax behavior. Both cultural factors, such as a weak tax culture, taxpayers' misconceptions of the tax system functions, and their intentions, and structural and macro factors, including political, economic, and social conditions, played roles in the voluntary or odd taxpayers' performance. For example, the results indicated that economic anomalies, self-interpretation of laws, lack of transparency of tax laws, and structural corruption played significant roles in the taxpayers' increased dissatisfaction and tendencies to evade taxes. Also, it could be said that one of the excuses and justifications made by the actors and taxpayers for tax evasion was a kind of covert protest against the structural conditions of the society, such as political distrust, social despair in improving the situation, expanded injustice, and lack of transparency in taxation and economy. In fact, taxation has lost its value and meaning and become as an anti-value in tandem with the improper structural conditions of the society, economy, and culture. All these have led to collective/national disorder, reproduction of anomic distrust, and very little development in tax systems.
Authors and Affiliations
Alireza Zare Ph. D. Student in Governmental Management, Department of Management, Faculty of Humanities, Islamic Azad University of Yazd, Yazd, Iran alireza. za2310@gmail. com Seyed Alireza Afshani* Professor, Department of Cooperatives and Social Welfare, Faculty of Social Sciences, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran afshanialireza@yazd. ac. ir Hossein Eslami Assistant Professor, Department of Management, Faculty of Humanities, Islamic Azad University of Yazd, Yazd, Iran h. eslami@iau. ac. ir Jalil Totoonchi Assistant Professor, Department of Management, Faculty of Humanities, Islamic Azad University of Yazd, Yazd, Iran ja. totonchi@yahoo. com Ali Ruhani Associated Professor, Department of Cooperatives and Social Welfare, Faculty of Social Sciences, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran aliruhani@yazd. ac. ir
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP706035
- DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.22108/jas.2022.131606.2228
- Views 85
- Downloads 0
Dissonance in Problem-Solving Pendolic Behaviors: Towards a Grounded Theory of Problem-Solving Formation among Yazdi Couples
Introduction One of the most important characteristics of every family is the way of communication and interactions between family members. This desirable communication would guarantee family health and consequently hea...
Investigating the social cleavage and the factors affecting it; Case study: Tehran
Introduction: Rapid cultural changes resulting from the transition from tradition to modernism, the cultural onslaught of the global capitalist system, the unequal distribution of resources, the transformation of social...
Democracy and Education: Testing Rival Perspectives (A Comparative Study of Cross-national Data from 1970 to 2018)
Introduction: The study of the relationship between the educational system and the political system has been one of the main concerns of sociologists in different eras (Bobba & Coviello, 2007). An important part of thes...
The Relationship between the Economic Action Pattern and Resilience in the Face of Crisis
Introduction After the 2008 crisis, the concept of resilience was introduced as one of the most important key factors in reducing vulnerability to crises. After this period, studies were more intensively done around thi...
A Sociological Analysis of the Effect of Economic Indicators on Homicide in Iran during 1995-2018
Introduction More than 464,000 people are killed each year worldwide. Homicide as a violent crime occurs in all countries, regardless of political, religious, or economic background. It is considered as a major public h...