Rationality and outcome of activity related treatment approach in the management of non-specific low back pain in young adults
Journal Title: National Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics - Year 2018, Vol 2, Issue 3
Abstract
Background: The occurrence of Non-specific low back pain is very common. 15% to 30% of the Young adults develop this condition. Some Orthopaedic surgeons commonly prescribe bed rest for Non-specific low back pain along with short term medication. On the other hand some Orthopaedic surgeons prescribe physical therapy and some prefer ordinary activity along with short term medication. Controversy persists over the most effective modality of treatment because of lack of evidence that any one of these modality of treatment is always effective. Aim of this study is to find out the most effective treatment approach for patients with Non-specific low back pain. Methods: The study is a retrospective, comparative, parallel group study, with three intervention groups. The study was done at our Institute during April 2016- July 2017. Patients of age between 21 to 45 Years presented with low back pain of less than 3 weeks duration with no history of trauma and no positive clinical findings were included in the study. Patients with neurologic signs, spondylolisthesis, and history of trauma, fever, weight loss, patients who received corticosteroid therapy, patients who had previous back surgery, pregnant females with low back pain and patients with other systemic disorder were excluded from the study. Patients who received bed rest for 3 days along with short term medication were labelled as Group A. Patients who received physical therapy with short term medication were labelled as Group B and Patients who received treatment according to the activity/work demands of the patient were labelled as Group C. Data on outcomes were collected during follow-up in outpatient department or on telephone. Outcomes of all patients were assessed at 1 month, 2 months and 3 months after completion of treatment. The assessment of outcome was focused on the effect of each modality of treatment on pain relief as measured on Visual Analogue Scale (VAS Score), the level of function and number of sick days. Results: We included 216 adult patients diagnosed as Non-specific low back pain fulfilling the inclusion criteria. Group A consisted of 69 patients who were treated with bed rest for 3 days and short term medication. Group B consisted of 73 patients who were treated with physical therapy and short term medication. Group C consisted of 74 patients who received treatment according to their activity/work demand. As compared with the patients in Group A and B, the Group C patients recovered significantly better in terms of VAS Score for pain, level of Function, the number of sick days. The median number of sick days was Seven in Group A and B Patients as against Five in Group C Patients. A statistical analysis was carried out using the SPSS software package. Conclusion: Our study results demonstrates that heavy manual labourers, sportsmen and military/police recruits with Non-specific low back pain respond better and earlier to 3 days of bed rest and short term medication as compared to physical therapy and short term medication. On the other hand office workers and those with light work responded better and earlier to physical therapy and short term medication. Hence Activity related treatment approach seems Rationale and leads to early functional recovery and less number of sick days.
Authors and Affiliations
Dr. Vijay Vasant Nemade, Dr. Atul A Patil
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP506935
- DOI -
- Views 49
- Downloads 0
Effect of intra-operative cell salvage in negating the need for allogenic transfusion in patients undergoing primary hip and knee arthroplasty
Introduction: Total joint arthroplasty is the operation of choice and a reliable option for end stage arthritis of the hip and knee. With a growing and aging population, the incidence of total hip and knee arthroplasty i...
To study outcomes of calcaneus fractures treated by conservative and surgical treatment according to AOFAS scoring system
Introduction: The calcaneus (os calcis) is the largest and most often fractured tarsal bone. It is the major weight bearing osseous structure of the foot and is one of the components of the tri-tarsal articulation and ha...
Open reduction internal fixation with plating versus external fixator in distal end radius fractures: A comparative study
Introduction: Low energy falls leading to stable variety of fracture patterns are seen most commonly, but young patients tend to have a high-energy mechanism of injury. Nonsurgical management remains main line of managem...
A prospective study of surgical management of fractures around ankle joint
Introduction: Ankle joint fractures are commonly encountered by orthopedic surgeons. Fractures are result of twisting and sport injuries. Ankle joint is maximum weight bearing joint of body and has maximum load per unit...
Management of Vancouver type B1 periprosthetic femoral shaft fracture by reversed contralateral distal femur locking plate
Background: Vancouver B1 periprosthetic femoral fractures are described as fractures occurring around the stem tip in which the prosthesis is stable. Treatment options include Mennen plates (CMW Laboratories, Exeter, En...