Rawzah al- Shuhada: from Spurious narratives to creating impression
Journal Title: تاریخ و فرهنگ - Year 2011, Vol 43, Issue 86
Abstract
Rawzah al- Shuhada, by Mulla Husayn Wa‘iz-i- kashifi (d. 910 A.H), is one of the most influential books on Karbala tragedy in recent centuries. Nevertheless, it has been criticized by the shi‘a scholars for spreading Spurious narratives among later works and public beliefes as well. The present article, discussing uncreditable narratives and falsifications in the work of Kashifi, intendes to investigate causes of its wide influence. The findings of the present study show that not all the unfounded narratives on the Karbala tragedies originated from Rawzah al- Shuhada since many of them are found in the earlier sources. Moreover, it was not the intention of Kashifi to write a history but to provide a simple comprehensive believabale report on the Karbala. These advantages, bringing acceptability for the work of Kashifi, made it the best available source for Shi‘a preachers and narrators of the tragedies of Karbala.
Authors and Affiliations
Mostafa Gohari Fakhrabad, Mohmmad Ali Kazembeyki Kazembeyki, Abdolrahim Ghanavat
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP191591
- DOI 10.22067/history.v0i0.9582
- Views 102
- Downloads 0
Slave Trade in Levant and its Impact on the Trend of Crusades)
Levant region (Eastern Mediterranean) has been of special importance in the history of commercial activities. In seventh/thirteenth century, two significant events influenced the development and prosperity of the commerc...
A Critical Review of the Historical Discourses Concerning Letter 36 in Translations and Commentaries of Nahj al-Balāgha
Plundering by Mu‘āwiya’s commanders in Imam ‘Alī’s (A.S.) jurisdiction began with the Ẓaḥḥāk b. Qays’s invasion and ended with the Busr b. Arṭāt’s massacre. The evidence and the analyses of the letter 36 of Nahj al-Balāg...
The Historical and Intellectual Course of Development in Preserving the Cultural Heritage from the Perspective of Conceptual Status of Integrity
Integrity is among the fundamental concepts in the field of cultural heritage and the importance of knowing this concept and examining its status in the philosophical principles of perseverance is so great that achieving...
The Ways Shī‘a Scholars Reacted to and Opposed the Activities of Presbyterian Missions in Mashhad during 1301-1309 sh.
American missions began widespread activities throughout Iran since Qajar periods and were mainly engaged in propagation in the form of establishing schools and medical institutes. For this purpose, they had constructed...
The Role of the Schools and Scholastic Islam in the Religious Politics of the Ottoman Government Case Study the Formation period up to the End of Murad I Period
The ruler-oriented attitude in the historiographical reports of the Ottoman period has caused the government to be portrayed as an impressive institution and the school, like most other institutions of the society, as im...