Reading Religiously across Religious Borders: A Method for Comparative Study
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2018, Vol 9, Issue 2
Abstract
Oliver Freiberger has done us the great service of drawing our attention to how comparativists do their comparative work. Issues of method—the “methodical aspects”—of course matter greatly in the actual doing of comparison, even if the scholar is not interested in theoretical discussions of method per se. One has to know one’s craft, in order to do it well, and to be clear in practice about how to proceed: “How comparison actually works as a method in the study of religion has not been discussed in greater detail so far. With due deliberation we can, as Freiberger suggests, identify and isolate specific methodical problems, effectively confront wholesale criticism, and find opportunities to refine the methodology. His approach also allows committed comparativists to speak in more depth about what we are doing in our research and writing.
Authors and Affiliations
Francis X. Clooney
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25910
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel9020042
- Views 347
- Downloads 8
From Contextual Theology to African Christianity: The Consideration of Adiaphora from a South African Perspective
The move towards contextual Christianity in Africa is an essential venture if Christianity is to communicate with the African cultural heritage. As a universal religion, Christianity has to find an expression within th...
“Rather More than One-Third Had No Jewish Blood”: American Progressivism and German-Jewish Cosmopolitanism at the New School for Social Research, 1933–1939
The New School for Social Research‘s University in Exile accepted more German and European exiled intellectuals than any other American institution of higher education. This paper argues that transnational, cosmopolita...
John Muir and “Godful” Nature
John Muir, America‘s most influential conservationist, held a special view of Nature, one that treated Nature as ―Godful‖ and ―unredeemed‖ because, unlike humankind, Nature has not ―fallen‖. It is a view that asks us t...
Res aut res publica: The Evidence from Italian Renaissance Manuscripts and Their Owners
This paper examines a key tension in Renaissance culture as reflected in the origin and provenance of manuscript books. Were Renaissance manuscripts the private property of individual owners or the common wealth of a l...
Spiritual Pathology: The Case of Adolf Hitler
Hitler had a noble purpose (to save the world) and a strong faith in the laws of Nature as he understood Nature. He was, then, a spiritual person, though his spirituality was pathological and destructive. Here, the exa...