Reviewing the impact of abuse and wastage in the lent (trust), a comparative study in Islamic jurisprudence and civil law
Journal Title: فقه و اصول - Year 2016, Vol 48, Issue 104
Abstract
Imamiyah jurists have had different views regarding the rights of the trustee in terms of abuse and wastage in the lent (trust); from the known theory of the claim for damages not being associated with the abuses and wastage on the basis of the generalities of the ‘on the hand’ rule to the theory of the relationship between fault and damage according to the general rules of liability and istīmān. Awareness to this issue will not be possible except through an investigation of the background and knowledge of the jurisprudential fundamentals of the known view among the jurists with regard to a lack of relationship between a claim for damages and abuse and wastage. Therefore, it is aimed in this paper to examine the conditions of the trustee in connection with the abuses and wastage first in Imamiyah jurisprudence and then in Iranian law. In this study, it is shown that the views of those jurists who consider as possible the domain of the trustee’s responsibility in terms of the involvement of a causal relationship with the abuses and wastage are more compatible with the ownership and possessive authority of the owner on his own property and the logical foundation stemming from istīmān rule.
Authors and Affiliations
Mostafa Karbalaee Aghazadeh, Reza Daryaee
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP190677
- DOI 10.22067/fiqh.v48i24.21066
- Views 95
- Downloads 0
A Jurisprudential Research in Material Value and Ownership of News in Mass Media and the Rights Resulting from it
Information dissemination throughout the society is carried out by a phenomenon called news. This phenomenon is in relation to various social institutions as well as different aspects of people’s lives. In the present ar...
A Research on the Nature of Aṣl-i Muḥriz (Confirming Principle) with an Emphasis on the Perspectives of Muḥaqqiq Nā’īnī and Shahīd Ṣadr
Although ‘Allāma Ḥillī and Shaykh Anṣārī have pointed out the feature of confirmation (iḥrāz) in some of the practical principles, its refinement has been one of Mīrzā-yi Nā’īnī’s initiatives. He divided the practical pr...
Execution of Legal Punishments in the Age of Occultation
Although our religious doctrines have given special importance to the execution of legal punishments and penalties for their conventional outcomes, the execution of legal punishments or their suspension in the age of occ...
Legal and Juridical Study of Qiṣāṣ through Donation of Organs
The applicability of executing the qiṣāṣ punishment through donation of organs is a novel topic and at the same time influential in safeguarding the blessings of human health and life. The legitimacy of this procedure re...
Examining the Relation between Ladies' Covering and Family Consolidation in Religious Doctrines
Men and women keeping company and formation of a family take place with different motives, one of which is fulfillment of sexual needs; however, using the term sukūn (tranquility), the Holy Qur’ān while promoting the fam...