Specters of Leviathan: Schmitt and Neumann on Law and State
Journal Title: Ankara Üniversitesi Dil ve Tarih-Coğrafya Fakültesi Dergisi - Year 2018, Vol 58, Issue 1
Abstract
The two of the main debates of the political philosophy in the 20th century occurred within the framework of the definition of totalitarian state as a new political form and the critique of the ideal of the rule of law. It could be asserted that through the political disputes of the Weimar Republic and the succeeding Third Reich, the German state theory has taken a central part in these two debates. The Nazi jurists’ effort to establish a legal basis for the Third Reich was criticized by the social democratic jurists in the post-war era. In this paper, through the critique of the rule of law carried out by both Carl Schmitt, the known chief jurist of the Nazi State, and Franz L. Neumann, one of the main thinkers of the Frankfurt School, how these two figures defined the concepts of law and the state and related them to one another will be discussed. Thus, both thinkers disagreed upon how the Nazi State could be defined in terms of its legal structure, and reached opposite conclusions while both took Hobbes’ Leviathan as a starting point in terms of the state definition. While Neumann diagnosed the Nazi state as the death of the Leviathan and the birth of the Behemoth, Schmitt argued contrarily, stating that what led to the death of the Leviathan had been the ideal of the rule of law and only a totalitarian Führer State [Führerstaat] could revive it. The debate between these two thinkers upon the concepts of law and the state inspired the problem which we could define as “the antinomy of the law” within the tradition of political philosophy. Interpreting this antinomy within the frame of such a debate will offer a suitable beginning in order to rethink the rule of law today.
Authors and Affiliations
Toros Güneş ESGÜN
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP631471
- DOI 10.33171/dtcfjournal.2018.58.1.42
- Views 102
- Downloads 0
On the Pop Fraction in 70s Polish Writers Expanded Upon Populism and Pop Culture
After the end of the communist regime, Poland entered a newphase of acceptance by adopting a new order established with democracy. New freedoms that came along with the new order in Poland led to a burst of “populism” an...
A Slight or a Stinging Ache?: The Freudian Uncanny in Harold Pinter's a Slight Ache
Set in a country house's relaxing atmosphere of a modest breakfast scene accompanied by a cup of marmalade, Pinter's A Slight Ache (1959) seems to present a world of utmost simplicity over where a sense of complete tranq...
The Andalusian Muwashshahs and Kharjas
The Qasidah was the unique form of classical Arabic poetry. However, with the expansion of the Islamic state by the conquests, some new poetry styles have emerged under the influence of neighboring cultures and social co...
From Suffragette to Diversity of Voices in Feminist Drama: Pam Gems’s Dusa, Fish, Stas and Vi
Feminist drama, as a suitable genre for the discussion of debates over different views within the feminist movement itself, developed in parallel with women’s movement. It is possible to find the examples of first-wave d...
Political State of Korea 1897-1910 and Daehan Empire
After the China-Japan war in 1897 with the end of China’s defeat, China started to lose its power. However, Japan emerged as another major power in the region after the Meiji Era. Korea moved away from long-term sovereig...