Spory o wykładnię znamion przestępstwa kradzieży energii (art. 278 § 5 k.k.) – czy prawnicy znają fizykę?
Journal Title: Studia Iuridica - Year 2017, Vol 72, Issue
Abstract
This article aims at analyzing the constituent elements of a criminal offense, based on Art. 278 § 5 k.k. The result of the analysis is the conclusion that in practice, only electricity can be the object of that offense. Therefore it must be specified accordingly in the provision of Art. 278 § 5 k.k. The study of literature led to the conclusion that the authors often mistakenly specify the object of that crime in a manner contrary to the principles of physics. This article presents the disputed issue of classifying the energy consumption by an entity authorized under an agreement with the provider, but with an understatement of the amounts of energy consumed by that entity. The author concluded that the classification of such act is possible based on Art. 278 § 5 and 286 § 1 k.k., depending on the definition of the result of an act which, at the time it was committed, was liable to evaluation under criminal law. The analysis also includes the controversial legal case of conscious use of energy consumed by the means of an illegal tapping into the power grid or causing a malfunction in a device designed to measure the amount of energy consumed by other persons who have not committed such an action. The study of literature led to the conclusion that according to the currently prevailing view such behavior does not fulfill the constituent elements of a crime. The author further concludes that due to the difficulties with the determination of the value of the object in question during the taking of evidence, the act of „stealing” electricity has rightly not undergone decriminalization; which could otherwise result in allegations on the grounds of infringement of the substantive law.<br/><br/>
Authors and Affiliations
Tomasz Tyburcy
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP345621
- DOI 10.5604/01.3001.0011.7635
- Views 78
- Downloads 0
Foreign Terrorist Fighters from the Perspective of Polish and European Criminal Law
Foreign terrorist fighters represent one of the powerful threats to the security of states and humanity in the 21st century. Besides participating in the actions of the Islamic State, they also pose a significant danger...
The Law School’s Role in Preparing Leaders and Lawyers for the New World
Autor na wstępie zauważa, że prawnicy zawsze odgrywali istotną rolę państwotwórczą nie tylko poprzez kreowanie porządku prawnego, ale także przywództwo polityczne, stając się „architektami demokracji” zarówno w Polsce, j...
Profesor Andrzej Murzynowski (1926–2016)
-<br/><br/>
Wpływ prac badawczych Profesora Witolda Czachórskiego na ewolucję odpowiedzialności państwa za szkody wyrządzone wykonywaniem władzy publicznej
In the course of the evolution of state liability for damages caused in the exercise of public authority the phenomenon of constitutionalisation can be observed, dating from Polish Constitution of March 1921, which guara...
Dziedzictwo prawne Leona Petrażyckiego w nowoczesnej doktrynie prawnej Ukrainy
The paper aims to study the work of Leon Petrazycki and analyze modern Ukrainian scholars’ opinions on Petrazycki’s scientific achievements. This study focuses on Petrazycki’s work, his psychological theory, in particula...