The Criticism of al-Albani to Bukhari
Journal Title: Mevzu – Journal of Social Sciences - Year 2019, Vol 0, Issue 2
Abstract
Since the time when the vaporium Muhammed b. Ismail al-Bukhari’s Camius Sahih was copyrighted, it gained a great reputation. He found fame as the most trusted book after the Quran, and explained that the ummah agreed with him that the narratives of Nesai were authentic and that they were deeds. On the other hand Darekutni (d. 303), Ebu Zer al-Herevi(d. 434),Ibn Hazm (d. 456), Ibn Abdi'l berr (d. 463), Ebu'l Velid al Baci (d. 474) and many other people have criticized al Camius Sahih. Albani Irva'ul-ğalil fi tahrici ehadisi menari’s-sebil, Silsuletu’l-ehadis’d-dâife ve'l mevzua and eseruhasseyyia fi'l -umme works, especially in his work criticized Bukhari and gave some Hadith weak judgment. In this article, two samples of Bukhari narrative and narrations that Albani criticized as "not real authentic" are examined. Here, Albani's critique form, the references on which it is based on the grounds of criticism are discussed in detail and other criticisims directed to this rumor are compared.
Authors and Affiliations
Hikmetullah ERTAŞ
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP649369
- DOI -
- Views 102
- Downloads 0
Siyasi ve Hukuki Açıdan Milli Mücadele (30 Ekim 1918-24 Temmuz 1923) Mustafa Turan, Berikan Yayınevi, 2011.
Siyasi ve Hukuki Açıdan Milli Mücadele (30 Ekim 1918-24 Temmuz 1923) Mustafa Turan, Berikan Yayınevi, 2011.
Fıkhi Açıdan Günümüz Para Mübadelesi İşlemleri –Spot ve Vadeli Forex İşlemler-. Abdullah Durmuş. İstanbul: İsam Yayınları 2014
Fıkhi Açıdan Günümüz Para Mübadelesi İşlemleri –Spot ve Vadeli Forex İşlemler-. Abdullah Durmuş. İstanbul: İsam Yayınları 2014
The Criticism of al-Albani to Bukhari
Since the time when the vaporium Muhammed b. Ismail al-Bukhari’s Camius Sahih was copyrighted, it gained a great reputation. He found fame as the most trusted book after the Quran, and explained that the ummah agreed wi...
Kamyon Arkası Yazılardan Yansıyan Dinsellik
The vehicle has taken an important place in Turkish social life. In fact, in many cases, the vehicle has different meanings than the function of moving people from one place to another. It is an object that expresses the...
Sosyoloji’nin Öğretmen Okullarında Ders Olarak Okutulmasına Yönelik Görüşler : İbrahim Alaaddin Gövsa ve Hilmi Ziya Ülken
In this study, the critical thoughts of the sociologists and educators of the statement after the decision taken in 1924 for the first time to include sociology in the teacher school curriculum will be discussed. İbrahim...