THE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE AND RELIGION OF FOREIGNERS IN POLISH LAW
Journal Title: Studia z Prawa Wyznaniowego - Year 2014, Vol 17, Issue 17
Abstract
According to Polish law foreigners do not have fully the same privileges as Polish citizens in the field of freedom of conscience and religion. The Constitution of 1997 allows the limitation of constitutional rights and freedoms of foreigners in comparison with Polish citizens by law. On the other hand, the principle of egalitarianism in the treatment of both groups is expressed in the most important acts of international law concerning the freedom of conscience and religion ratified or signed by Polish authorities. Nevertheless, the best guarantee of equal treatment of foreigners and citizens in the area of that freedom could only be fully provided due to the ratification of Protocol No. 12 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of 1950. Moreover, Polish accession to the most vital legal acts protecting the status of stateless persons (from 1954 and 1961) is highly recommended Consequently, the requirement of having native citizenship by Polish bishops provided by the Polish Concordat in 1993 should be assessed critically as the manifestation of the perception of the Catholic Church hierarchy in political terms as well as the discrimination of the Catholic religion. The above mentioned allegations, which can be supplemented with the charges of the breach of the principle of independence and autonomy of the relevant confessions, or even the violation of freedom of conscience and religion of the foreigners, can be put against the provisions of the Polish legislation, which conditions holding managerial functions in some religious associations on having Polish citizenship. There are significant limitations to the system of relations between the State and religious associations. The most far-reaching restriction of the religious freedoms concerning foreigners seems to be the ban on their membership in the Jewish religious communities, and above all, the lack of an opportunity to apply for the registration of a religious association. All of the above mentioned legislative restrictions should be immediately abolished as they do not correspond with the reality of social relations, particularly in an international context. Their maintenance might cause a failure of Polish authorities in case they were sued by the international human rights and freedoms organizations. Additionally, the restrictions of freedom in religious matters concerning foreigners also have objective and non-discriminatory nature, ie. they are the same as the restrictions concerning Polish citizens. In particular, they derive from socio-political condition of contemporary Poland. Unfortunately, our country is still ethnically and religiously homogenical. This factor continuously affects Polish legislation after the year1989. At the same time, neither the case law of ordinary courts nor the case law of the Supreme Court or even the Constitutional Court have fulfilled the liberalizing function in the broadest sense of freedom of conscience and religion.
Authors and Affiliations
Paweł Borecki
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP137712
- DOI -
- Views 221
- Downloads 0
A PROPOSAL OF THE 2008 ACT ON THE PROPERTY AND FINANCING OF CHURCHES AND RELIGIOUS DENOMINATIONS IN THE CZECH REPUBLIC IN THE LIGHT OF THE BINDING CONCORDAT AGREEMENTS WITH POSTCOMMUNIST STATES
The article presents the proposals of the law on property settlement with churches and religious societies and on their financing prepared by the Government of the Czech Republic in 2008, especially in comparison with...
STANOWISKO ŚWIADKÓW JEHOWY WOBEC WYBRANYCH WSPÓŁCZESNYCH PROCEDUR MEDYCZNYCH
Obecnie Świadkowie Jehowy w Polsce są zarejestrowanym związkiem wyznaniowym wpisanym pod numerem 34 do Rejestru kościołów i innych związków wyznaniowych prowadzonego przez Ministra Spraw Wewnętrznych i Administracji. Dok...
ACCESSIBILITY OF USING OF THE RELIGIOUS CONTENT ON THE INDIVIDUAL REGISTRATION PLATES OF VEHICLES IN POLAND
According to the aforementioned legal regulations it results that the Polish legal system allows registration of a vehicle with an individual registration plate from as late as the 21st of September of 2002. The individu...
KWALIFIKACJE OGÓLNE DO NAUCZANIA RELIGII W SZKOŁACH I PRZEDSZKOLACH PUBLICZNYCH
Wymagania kwalifikacyjne do nauczania religii w przedszkolach i szkołach publicznych w Polsce określane są w porozumieniach zawieranych pomiędzy poszczególnymi kościołami a Ministrem Edukacji Narodowej. W artykule niniej...
ZAKRES IMPLEMENTACJI PRZEPISÓW KONKORDATU DOTYCZĄCYCH ZAWIERANIA MAŁŻEŃSTW CYWILNYCH W FORMIE WYZNANIOWEJ DO SYSTEMU PRAWA POLSKIEGO
Przedmiotem niniejszego artykułu jest analiza problemu dotyczącego sposobu i zakresu implementacji postanowień konkordatu zawartego między Stolicą Apostolską i Rzecząpospolitą Polską w 1993 r. dotyczących wyznaniowej for...