The Justice Condition in Hadith and the Justice Issue of the Companions in the Shia’a
Journal Title: Mütefekkir - Year 2015, Vol 2, Issue 3
Abstract
The dictionary meaning of justice is based on truth and honesty. Reliability of the narrator is a condition in the Hadith.The Hadith metodologists discussed five conditions for that justice that are 1- the lie of narrator, 2- accusing the narrator of being a lair, 3- sinfulness of narrator, 4-people who creat Beda’a (بدعة)in religion, 5- and being ignorant.With these statements they accepted that a person's justice is related to these conditions. These conditions are necessary for all the narrators except the Companions. Sunni scholars have considered all the companions as reliable, that’s why, they don’t criticize them.Shia agrees with Sunni scholars on the definition of the companion, however, they think differently about their justice. Although there are some differences between them, they went on to criticize many of the Companions for different reasons. They even go further and accuse some of the Companions of being disbelievers.In this study, we will examine the evidence of the Shia and the appeals of Ahl al-Sunnah. That ‘s why we carry out this assessment.
Authors and Affiliations
Harun Reşit DEMİREL
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP617071
- DOI 10.30523/mutefekkir.130248
- Views 148
- Downloads 0
Konu Hadisleri Bağlaminda Mescid-i Nebevî ve Orada Yapılan İbadetlerin Fazileti
İbadet maksadıyla ziyaret edilebilecek üç mescidden biri olan Mescid-i Nebî, İslamın on kusur yıllık Medine döneminin yönetim merkezi, istişare mekânı ve en önemlisi de ibadet merkezi gibi birçok fonksiyonu yerine getir-...
Ontology of Goodness and Evil in Avicenna
A philosophical investigation focusing on the nature of goodness and evil constitutes one of the most abstract areas of discussion of philosophical thought. This study, aims to maintain a discussion on the ontological di...
Hz. Peygamber’in İslâm Tebliğine Karşı Şair ve Siyasî Liderlerin İlk Tavırları ve Şiir Alanında Yaşanan Gelişmeler
Siyasî lider ve şairler toplumların önemli şahsiyetleridir. Siyasî liderler, toplumun malî ve idarî tasarruf kuvvetini, şairler ise toplumun duygu ve heyecan gücünü ellerinde bulundururlar. Dolayısıyla her iki kesim de t...
Peygamberlerin İsmet Sıfatının Kur’ân Yorumlarına Etkisi (Hz. Âdem Örneği)
Bu çalışma Peygamberlerin sıfatlarından olan ismet inancının Kur’an yorumlarını nasıl etkilediğini Hz. Âdem kıssası örneğinde incelemeyi amaçlamaktadır. Kur’an’ın yorumuna etki eden âmillerden birisi de İslam düşüncesind...
Scientific İnterpretation and Change
In the Holly Book Quran, which has been sent as a source of the true path for the man kind, different methods and styles were used in order to achieve this purpose. Especially the ayahs (verses) in which the existence of...