The New Secular Humanists: Ronald Dworkin and Philip Kitcher on Life without God
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2015, Vol 6, Issue 3
Abstract
Ronald Dworkin and Philip Kitcher recognize that traditional, religious faith—especially in Christian theistic tradition—has virtues that seem to be missing in a secular worldview. To remedy this apparent deficit, they both propose that a secular worldview can provide a satisfying foundation for a flourishing, meaningful life. Moreover, Kitcher argues that secular humanism is far more justified than a religious worldview because it does not face the problem of diversity that arises in the case of religion. I argue that secular humanism faces the same problem of diversity that Kitcher proposes undermines religious belief. I further argue that Dworkin’s and Kitcher’s secular alternative to a religious worldview is problematic.
Authors and Affiliations
Charles Taliaferro
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25460
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel6030839
- Views 301
- Downloads 8
Intergenerational Transmission of Religious Giving: Instilling Giving Habits across the Life Course
This paper investigates the research question: How do religious youth learn to give? While it is likely that youth learn religious financial giving from a variety of different sources, this investigation focuses primar...
Ambassadors for the Kingdom of God or for America? Christian Nationalism, the Christian Right, and the Contra War
This essay uses the concept of Christian nationalism to explore the religious dynamics of the Contra war and U.S.–Nicaraguan relations during Ronald Reagan’s presidency. Religious organizations and individuals played c...
God, Evil, and Infinite Value
Prominent approaches to the problems of evil assume that even if the Anselmian God exists, some worlds are better than others, all else being equal. But the assumptions that the Anselmian God exists and that some world...
“There Is a Higher Height in the Lord”: Music, Worship, and Communication with God
Music is so vital in the services of African American Baptist churches that there are few moments in the service when music—either congregational or choral singing, or instrumental music of some sort—is not being perfo...
Can We Move Beyond the Secular State?
The article argues for re-consideration of the secularization so often in the West regarded as an essential condition for a democratic state. Its inbuilt incoherence and problematic consequences suggest that the term s...