The Portrayal of Korea: A Critical Analysis of Korean History in American Secondary Schools
Journal Title: International Journal of Korean History - Year 2000, Vol 1, Issue 1
Abstract
This paper attempts to review Korean history as depicted in world history textbooks for American secondary schools. Since Korean history presented within these textbooks will have a great influence on how students perceive Korea and understand Korean history, they should be written in an accurate and coherent manner, and well-integrated with supplementary texts to effectively promote reader comprehension. It is therefore essential to select and narratively reconstruct core historical events and to organize chapters in consideration of their educational impact on the comprehension of Korean history. This study thus attempts to analyze the depiction of Korean history in terms of coherence, topic selection, accuracy, and perspective with attention given to the coherence and effectiveness of supplementary sections, in contrast to previous studies that focused only on examining historical accuracy. The four world history textbooks examined are considered representative textbooks, are the most widely used in the U.S. secondary schools to date, and cover ancient through modem world history. Pedagogical problems proliferate in the historical accounts and supplementary sections on Korean history in textbooks. Outright errors and bias in the selection and interpretation of history have been noted that will unintentionally mislead students in their interpretation of the Korean past that may be largely determined by the Eurocentric perspective that informs the narration of Korean history.
Authors and Affiliations
Seon-mee Kim
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP26245
- DOI -
- Views 626
- Downloads 27
Through the Prism of Masquerade: The Colonial Past in Assassination
Assassination marks a new phase of colonial representation in South Korean cinema. To explicate the film’s unique, if not revisionist, view toward the colonial past, this review focuses on an analysis of how the film...
Ch’oe Ch’iwŏn’s P’ungnyudo and Present-day Hallyu
P’ungnyudo, originating from the ancient societies, was based on belief in the heavens and native beliefs, but it was also open to and accepting of the teachings of foreign religions such as Confucianism, Buddhism, and D...
The Minjung’s Perception of Japan During the Period Immediately Following the Kanghwa Treaty (1876~1884) and Their Response to Japan
No Abstract
The Korean National Defense Student Defense Corps and the Manufacturing of Warrior-type Students in Its Incipient Days
Before and after the official inauguration of the Republic of Korea (ROK), not a few South Korean students opposed the polity, resisting it even at the cost of their lives. They vehemently inveighed against the polity fo...
The Protestant Church as a Political Training Ground in Modern Korea
A great majority of the personages on the political scene right after the liberation in 1945 were Protestant church leaders and members. In addition to moderate to left-wing leaders such as Kim Kyusik, Yo Unhyong, Kan...