The Role of Complex Systems Theory in Harmonising Non-Financial Reporting for Sustainable Finance in Zimbabwean Commercial Banks
Journal Title: Journal of Accounting, Finance and Auditing Studies - Year 2024, Vol 10, Issue 4
Abstract
This study investigates the harmonising potential of complex systems theory in non-financial reporting of sustainable finance practices within Zimbabwean commercial banks. The increasing prominence of sustainable finance in Zimbabwe can be attributed to the adoption of international frameworks such as the United Nations’ 2030 Agenda and the Paris Agreement, which have led to its integration into banks' non-financial reporting. Sustainable finance, however, is recognised as a wicked problem—an issue characterised by its complexity, involving numerous interacting agents, emergent properties, and the need for a holistic approach. Such problems cannot be adequately addressed through conventional financial theories, which are often insufficient to capture their complexity. Despite the existence of various sustainability reporting standards, a unified framework to harmonise non-financial reporting and enable comparability across banks is still lacking. Using content analysis, this research examines annual reports from 17 Zimbabwean commercial banks, analysing 136 reports spanning from 2016 to 2023. The findings suggest that most banks have adopted a weak sustainability approach, guided by complex systems theory, which enables some degree of harmonisation in reporting standards but ultimately compromises long-term sustainability. This weak approach has been found to encourage greenwashing practices, with policies and strategies that, while aligned with sustainability rhetoric, may perpetuate environmental and social harm. The study makes several key contributions: it provides empirical evidence on the current state of sustainable finance reporting in Zimbabwean banks, offers a theoretical framework for harmonising non-financial reporting using complex systems theory, and proposes the adoption of a stronger sustainability-oriented framework to ensure genuine, long-term sustainability outcomes.
Authors and Affiliations
Gilbert Tepetepe
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP752499
- DOI https://doi.org/10.56578/jafas100404
- Views 11
- Downloads 0
Maltese Stakeholder Perceptions of the Elements and Values in the Cooperative Concept
The exploration of stakeholder perceptions concerning the elements and values underpinning the cooperative concept in Malta forms the core objective of this investigation. Employing semi-structured interviews, primary da...
Impact of IPO Review Inquiry Intensity on Prospectus Information Disclosure Updates
The prospectus, as the primary vehicle for issuers to disclose information to the public, plays a crucial role in protecting investors’ rights. Review inquiries serve as an important tool to ensure the quality of the pro...
Benchmarking Sustainable Performance in Shareholder Wealth Creation: A Data Envelopment Analysis Approach
The evaluation of companies' sustainability performance in generating shareholder wealth is increasingly reliant on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) ratings. This study introduces a novel approach by applying...
Determinants of Human Capital Disclosure in the Mining Industry: Comparative Analysis of South African and Zimbabwean Companies
The mining sector plays a pivotal role in the economies of South Africa and Zimbabwe, yet limited attention has been given to the determinants of human capital disclosure within this industry. This study aims to address...
Impact of ERP System Implementation on Accounting Information Quality in Vietnamese SMEs
This research explores the influence of enterprise resource planning (ERP) system implementation on the quality of accounting information in Vietnamese small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). ERP systems, designed to...