The Role of History and the Past in Discussions of Nationalism: A Comparative Analysis of the Theories of Eric J. Hobsbawm and Anthony D. Smith
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2016, Vol 6, Issue 2
Abstract
Academic discussions of nationalism have been flourishing to such an extent that after 1980 some scholars began to publish important analyses of its various aspects from new perspectives. Still, topics such as culture, politics, ethnicity and race have not been focused on in terms of these two concepts. This article focuses on the relationship among “history,” “the past” and nationalism in the works of Eric J. Hobsbawm (1917-2012) and Anthony D. Smith (1939-2016) and the roles they attribute to them. I have selected these two scholars for the first one is a spokesman for modernism, whereas the second one supports ethno-symbolism. In addition, they are currently the most controversial names in the field. My main goal is to prove the existence of either “history” or “the past” in the frequently used ancient-modern contrast as regards discussions on nationalism, its justifications and related topics.
Authors and Affiliations
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP315919
- DOI 10.12658/human.society.6.12.M0189
- Views 53
- Downloads 0
Diaspora Concept and a Socio-Political Analysis of Turkey’s Diaspora Politics in the Context of Modern Theory
Diaspora is one of the most important social and political events of our time. Diaspora theory is considered within two different approaches, classical and modern. Our work at this point has taken both approaches into ac...
Obedience or Resistance: Muslim Conception of Time as a Reaction to the Authoritarian Turkish Modernization
While considerations of Turkish modernization become more varied through studies with a social historical perspective, the limited number of alternative readings of the relationship between religion, state, and society i...
Doctor Abdullah Cevdet’s Perception of Religion
Doctor Abdullah Cevdet, who lived in a period in which trends of western origin were spreading rapidly in the Ottoman territory, is among the individuals who have been frequently discussed because of the ideas he defende...
From Good Sense to Good Pleasure: The First Use and Meaning of the Word “Literature”
The idea that the word “literature” (edebiyat) was derived from the Arabic word of “edeb” gained a prevalence in academy. Despite debates about how long this word has been used, it is a widely accepted claim that it star...
Komşuyu Anlamak/Anlatmak: 20. Yüzyılda Türkiye’de İran’a Dair Yayınlanan Kitaplara Dair Bir Değerlendirme
İran ve Türkiye, tarih boyunca dinî, siyasi, kültürel, edebî vb. açılardan etkileşim içinde bulunan iki ülke olagelmiştir. Kaşgarlı Mahmud asırlar önce, “Tatsız Türk bolmaz (Farssız Türk olmaz).” diyerek bu ilişkilerin d...