The Significance of Being Ethical: An essay on the case for moral realism and theism
Journal Title: Scientia et Fides - Year 2016, Vol 4, Issue 1
Abstract
William Irwin defends a form of moral anti-realism, according to which there are no objective moral facts. He contends that moral realism is objectionable because of its being more complex or not as simple as anti-realism; moral realism is in conflict with science; moral realism is also challenged by the fact that our moral judgements would differ if we were subject to a different biology or evolutionary past. Irwin also argues that insofar as moral realism is supportable evidentially by experience this would lead to the absurdity of thinking theism may be supported evidentially by religious experience. In response, it is argued that there are many truths (about logic and mathematics) and practices (such as science itself) that are not intelligible if there are no objective, normative truths and that objective moral truths are no more dispensable or odd than epistemic norms. It is further argued that Irwin's account of the evolution of morality is not able to escape presupposing objective moral facts (about harm and benefaction). Finally, the appeal to moral and religious experience is defended in making the case for moral realism and theism.
Authors and Affiliations
Charles Taliaferro
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP195097
- DOI 10.12775/SetF.2016.003
- Views 84
- Downloads 0
Razón práctica y primer principio de la ley natural en Suárez
Practical reason and first principle of the natural law in Suárez The aim of this paper is to examine the Suarecian theory of practical reason and its first principle, which is also the first principle of natural law. A...
El bien como objeto del querer. Suárez y los presupuestos apetitivos y cognoscitivos de la acción racional
The good as the object of wanting. Suárez on the appetitive and cognitive conditions of rational action This paper discusses Suárez’s characterization of the formal object of wanting, i.e. the good. Wanting, in all its...
Il costante progredire della frontiera tra teologia e scienza: “Fisica”
On constant movement of frontiers between Theology and Science: Physics Pope Benedict XVI wrote in 1979 in “Four sermons on the Creation of world” that scientific discoveries cause a kind of retreat of the faith on “def...
On Artigas and Analytic Philosophy
This essay, written on the occasion of the 10th anniversary of Mariano Artigas’s death, examines Artigas’s engagement with analytic philosophy in his philosophy of science. I argue that, overall, Artigas’s project in the...
Guidelines for authors
Wytyczne dla autorów