The Social False Dilemma: Perpetuating Conflicts between Liberals and Conservatives
Journal Title: Res Rhetorica - Year 2019, Vol 6, Issue 1
Abstract
This essay addresses the establishment of a social false dilemma in the form of the socially-constructed categories of liberals and conservatives. The illogical positioning of only two options for solving a problem reduces an audience’s ability for developing creative solutions. The dichotomous nature of this political positioning undercuts critical thought through politicians’ usage of entrenched either-or thinking. In turn, the people struggle with a deliberative process that is underscored by an acceptance of a false dilemma. In particular, this essay focuses on an American dichotomous political climate by acknowledging the existence of the dichotomy, the promotion of Dissoi Logoi to avoid the false dilemma, and the repercussions of compromised deliberative functions of democracy.
Authors and Affiliations
Brent Kice
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP509527
- DOI 10.29107/rr2019.1.4
- Views 98
- Downloads 0
W trosce o nieprzedstawienie – wizerunek Józefa Stalina na łamach czasopism społeczno-kulturalnych okresu stalinizmu w Polsce
W okresie Polski Ludowej (oraz Polskiej Rzeczpospolitej Ludowej) sposób komentowania aktualnych zdarzeń przez czasopisma społeczno-kulturalne był sprawdzianem politycznej poprawności, do której były one zmuszane przez ów...
Dyskurs instytucjonalny w Polsce – dobre i złe praktyki komunikacyjne
This synthetic article is devoted to the linguistic dimensions of administrative power. It surveys current good and bad communicative practices and indicates how they have been changing under the evolving social, politic...
O niektórych aspektach związanych z etosem w argumentum ad crumenam
Celem tego artykułu jest analiza wybranych aspektów związanych z etosem w argumencie ad crumenam, rozpatrywanym jako złożona technika retoryczna. Przyjęte metody badawcze obejmują dwa podejścia z zakresu pragmatyki: teor...
The rhetorical construction of Hillary Rodham Clinton as a presidential contender in 2016: A case study of hillaryclinton.com
This article reviews some of the rhetorical means of constructing the image of Hillary Rodham Clinton as a presidential contender in 2016 election campaign. It explores this in the context of research on “gendered” polit...
Negative TV Advertising in the 2016 US Presidential Campaign
Presented research describes the character of message and techniques used in TV political advertising during the 2016 US presidential campaign. The results unambiguously indicate a steady increase in the use of negative...