The Usefulness and Effectiveness of Argumentative Writing Self-assessment Checklist in Undergraduate Writing Classrooms
Journal Title: International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences - Year 2018, Vol 8, Issue 4
Abstract
Writing instruction in the ESL classroom has evolved dramatically over the last few decades. Now, the focus has shifted from the final product of writing to the process of writing. The writing process is divided into three main stages: prewriting, writing and rewriting (Murray, 1985). This change has encouraged educators to look for strategies that focus on the writing process systematically and involve the learners to be focused and active at every stage of writing. One of the strategies that has been gaining popularity is self-assessment. It refers to teaching methods such as self-assessment checklist that prompt student writers to carefully think about, assess and respond to their written work systematically (Nielson, 2014). This study investigates the perception of teachers and students on the usefulness of a self-assessment checklist to assist students in the argumentative writing. Self-assessment Checklist for Undergraduate Argumentative Writing designed by Nimehchisalem et al. (2014) is used in this study. Feedback was obtained from four university writing lecturers through the Delphi method. The checklist was then implemented in the undergraduate writing classroom for a period of five weeks and students’ perception on the usability of the checklist was recorded through interviews. Observations were made to understand the implementation process of the checklist. From the experts’ feedback, a few changes were made to the checklist by adding, deleting, rewording and re-arranging items to ensure the checklist is more user- friendly. The experts perceived the checklist to be an effective tool in that it would reduce their workload especially regarding the amount of time spent providing feedback to the students. Students reported the checklist motivated them to write, created awareness on their writing ability, enhanced their understanding of argumentative writing, made them independent writers, and assisted them in writing more systematically. The observation enlightened the researchers on the items that needed more assistance or explanation from teacher during the training session.
Authors and Affiliations
Kayatri Vasu, Vahid Nimehchisalem, Yong Mei Fung, Sabariah Md Rashid
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP560787
- DOI 10.6007/IJARBSS/v8-i4/4008
- Views 99
- Downloads 0
Cross-Cultural Perspectives on the Differences in Food and Culinary Customs between the Chinese and Shona Societies with figurative Language as Point of Reference
The present study falls under social linguistics. In this study we attempt to use figurative language to compare Chinese and Shona societies. The central argument of the research in anchored by the claim that, figurative...
Factors Influencing Sustainability of Rural Water Supplies Management in Kenya: A Case Study of Marakwet West Sub County, Elgeyo Marakwet County, Kenya
The purpose of this project was to analyse the Factors influencing Sustainability of Rural Water Supplies Management in Kenya: A Case Study of Marakwet West Sub County Elgeyo Marakwet County Kenya. It was specially want...
Collective Leadership among Secondary School Teachers
To date the increasing trend in the teaching fraternity is moving towards one where members of an educational institution play a managerial role. The term given to this style of leading is collective leadership and it is...
The Awareness of Islamic Branding among Modern Malay Muslim Women (MMW)
This article investigates the understanding of Islamic branding of products and services on modern Malay Muslim women (MMW). It is set against a significant phenomenon in Malaysia where modern MMW struggle with purchase...
The Pilot Study of Student’s Pharmacy Awareness of Al Quran and Prophet Muhammad Dietary and Practices, And the Coherency of Medicinal Properties Characteristics
Islam has given the ideas and guidelines to people in all aspects of life such as law, economy, science and social. The Quran has cited many items of health related, while hadeeth and sunnah of Prophet Muhammad were the...