THEORETICAL BASICS OF SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
Journal Title: Zeszyty Naukowe Wyższej Szkoły Finansów i Prawa w Bielsku-Białej - Year 2016, Vol 1, Issue 3
Abstract
The paper is a theoretical consideration on the scientific evidence in a criminal proceeding, presented as following: the explanation of the term “scientific evidence”, the review of the existing definitions of scientific evidence (i.e. by methodological, methodical and normative enumeration), a proposal of a general, classic definition of the scientific evidence. It also shows criteria to identify the “correctness” of the scientific evidence, from inter-subjective controllability and communication, validation of the test method, interpretation of the results of its application with the use of a likelihood ratio, up to a critical analysis of Frey’s standard and Daubert’s standard. The paper concludes with a discussion on selected concepts of the scientific evidence assessment for the purposes of criminal proceedings.
Authors and Affiliations
Anna Ibek, Monika Suchojad
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP193084
- DOI 10.19192/wsfip.sj3.2016.10
- Views 75
- Downloads 0
DZIAŁANIA WYBRANYCH FORMACJI MUNDUROWYCH NA RZECZ POPRAWY BEZPIECZEŃSTWA NA OBSZARACH I TERENACH KOLEJOWYCH W POLSCE
Celem opracowania jest przedstawienie roli Policji oraz Straży Ochrony Kolei w zakresie zapewnienia bezpieczeństwa na obszarach i terenach kolejowych w Polsce. Omówiono ustawowe zadania i formy ich realizacji przez te fo...
RELEASE OF PROPERTY – SELECTED ISSUES
The issue mentioned in the title of this paper embraces a number of questions referring to the scope of powers of a court bailiff, levying execution on the basis of an enforceable title that pledges a debtor to release t...
EMPLOYER`S LIABILITY FOR DAMAGES IN DISCRIMINATION CASES
The paper describes practical problems relating to normalization of discrimination in labour law. It is about the role of compensation for discrimination, regardless of whether one takes into account either a compensator...
LEGAL AND ORGANISATIONAL CONDITIONS OF MONUMENTS PROTECTION IN THE EVENT OF ARMED CONFLICT OR EMERGENCIES
The protection of historic properties in case of an armed conflict and crisis situations should be a part of public tasks. The fundamental act regulating the issue of the historic buildings preservation in Poland is the...
PRAWNE I KRYMINOLOGICZNE ASPEKTY GWAŁTU PRZY UŻYCIU PIGUŁKI GWAŁTU
Gwałt to bardzo poważne przestępstwo, a badania nad ofiarami gwałtu wykazuj że bardzo często cierpi one z powodu traumy wywołanej tym zdarzeniem. W dzisiejszych czasach coraz częściej ofiary zostają odurzane specjalnymi...