Therapeutic Theodicy? Suffering, Struggle, and the Shift from the God’s-Eye View
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2018, Vol 9, Issue 4
Abstract
From a theoretical standpoint, the problem of human suffering can be understood as one formulation of the classical problem of evil, which calls into question the compatibility of the existence of a perfect God with the extent to which human beings suffer. Philosophical responses to this problem have traditionally been posed in the form of theodicies, or justifications of the divine. In this article, I argue that the theodical approach in analytic philosophy of religion exhibits both morally and epistemically harmful tendencies and that philosophers would do better to shift their perspective from the hypothetical “God’s-eye view” to the standpoint of those who actually suffer. By focusing less on defending the epistemic rationality of religious belief and more on the therapeutic effectiveness of particular imaginings of God with respect to suffering, we can recover, (re)construct, and/or (re)appropriate more virtuous approaches to the individual and collective struggle with the life of faith in the face of suffering.
Authors and Affiliations
Amber L. Griffioen
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25966
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel9040099
- Views 351
- Downloads 21
“I Heard the Voice. I Felt the Presence”: Prayer, Health and Implications for Clinical Practice
Research concerning the relation between physical health and prayer typically employs an outcome oriented paradigm and results are inconsistent. This is not surprising since prayer per se is not governed by physiologic...
Adam Smith, the Impartial Spectator and Embodiment: Towards an Economics of Accountability and Dialogue
This article argues that Adam Smith’s notion of sympathy and the impartial spectator in his work The Theory of Moral Sentiments [1759] connects the individual to society. In this work, Smith’s economics are far more co...
The Division of the Roman Catholic Church in Mainland China: History and Challenges
The paper offers a historical perspective on the division within the Roman Catholic Church in mainland China, focusing on the appointment of bishops, the constitution of ecclesial provinces and dioceses, and the proble...
Validation of the SpREUK—Religious Practices Questionnaire as a Measure of Christian Religious Practices in a General Population and in Religious Persons
Measures of spirituality should be multidimensional and inclusive and as such be applicable to persons with different worldviews and spiritual-religious beliefs and attitudes. Nevertheless, for distinct research purpos...
Explaining Support for Sectarian Terrorism in Pakistan: Piety, Maslak and Sharia
In the discourse around sectarian violence in Pakistan, two concerns are prominent. The first is the contention that piety, or the intensity of Muslim religious practice, predicts support for sectarian and other forms...