Unpacking the Paradox of Student-Involvement Quality Promotion Nexus: Knowing Where to Draw the Line and Implications Thereof
Journal Title: International Journal of Social Science And Human Research - Year 2022, Vol 5, Issue 01
Abstract
Student-involvement in higher-education is necessary for quality-assurance outcomes, yet such involvement also threatens attainment of quality assured, presenting the paradox of higher-education (HE) systems. With the massification of enrolment-figures across the HE sector has been the need to balance HEI and student-centred perspectives. The notion of students as co-producers, consumers, and products of HEI processes creates discord in the quality assurance arena. Contradictory problems manifest when the producer must satisfy the consumer and audit quality of the products, yet students are all of these. This article explored the extent to which student-involvement fosters quality as well as sets parameters beyond which such participation cannot be done without compromising quality-assurance and desired academic-success. The artile drew a line for student-involvement and quality- assurance as double-barreled and sometimes paradoxical, contradictory pursuits. Data elicited from two HEIs in Zimbabwe using the questionnaire method and analysed using Microsoft Excel package generated descriptive frequencies and related graphs and charts to present findings. Documents were analysed using thematic content analysis to glean for relevant secondary data. Student-involvement is marred by unclear parameters at the three confluences of ‘students as co-producers’; ‘students as consumers’; and ‘students as products’ of HEI quality-assurance processes students should participate in, consume, and be products of. Derolling is thus necessary for students to function in various capacities as as co-producers, consumers, or as products. Students as ‘co-producers’ cannot be expected to produce themselves through ‘students as products’, neither can they be ‘consumers’ themselves while being the ‘product’ to be consumed by industry and communities through employment and innovation. The National Assembly should address contradictions through amending HEI-establishing Acts to cede policy making powers to the University Councilsacting jointly with senior management of universities. As co-producers, students involvement should be unlimited at governance levels (by different HEI students) while as consumers (within particular HEIs), student involvement should be limited to lower rungs at consumer level to avoid contradictions that potentially compromise quality. As HEI products, students should be limited to Alumni activities as main function should clearly differentiate among the various roles when crafting HEI policies that foster student involvement.
Authors and Affiliations
Mthuthukisi Ncube, Francis Godfrey Ncube, Excellence Charles Mateke
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP704160
- DOI 10.47191/ijsshr/v5-i1-28
- Views 54
- Downloads 0
Strengthening Character Education in Formal Education Units Based on Minister Regulation of Education and Culture Republic of Indonesia (Study at Public Alementary School Pakong 1, Pakong District, Pamekasan Regency, Indonesia)
Indonesia is one of the countries that has experienced difficulties in implementing public policies, one of which is the implementation of the regulation of the Minister of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indone...
Psychological Research on Drug-related Crimes in Vietnam from the Criminological Perspective
In recent times, despite the situation of the Covid-19 epidemic has had serious developments on a global scale, drug crimes in the world, in the region and in the country have continued to be very complicated. Southeast...
Improving Student' Historical Thinking Skills Using the Inquiry-Based Learning Model
The aim of this study is verifying students' historical thinking skills using the inquiry-based learning model. Inquiry-based learning model can involve students actively in the process of building knowledge through rese...
Analysis of the Readiness of Preservice Teachers in Implementing Teaching Practices
This research aims to analyze the readiness of students from the Chemistry Education Department to implement the Teaching Practices (PPL) program in 2023. This type of research is descriptive qualitative with a phenomeno...
Validity of Paragraph Writing Skills Teaching Materials Based on Qur'ani Idiomatic Patterns
This study aims to (1) develop teaching materials for Arabic paragraph writing skills based on Quranic idiomatic patterns; and (2) describe the feasibility of teaching materials for Arabic paragraph writing skills based...