Usefulness of Demirjian’s Stages in Determining the Age of Majority: A Study on South Indian Population
Journal Title: Journal of Indian Academy of Forensic Medicine - Year 2017, Vol 39, Issue 2
Abstract
In consideration of the constant increase in juvenile crimes or illegal immigration, need of a reliable means to determine the age of an individual and his/her attainment of age of majority remains to be a fundamental requirement in forensic practice. Mincer et al. in 2009 verified the usefulness of Demirjian tooth developmental stages in discrimination of juvenile/adult status. The third molars are the only available growing teeth during the period of late adolescence and considered to be the reliable biological markers for this purpose. The purpose of this study was to verify the usefulness of Demirjian’s stages of root development in discriminating adults and minors in South- Indian individuals. For this purpose, a sample of 506 (227 males and 279 females) orthopantomograms aged between 14 and 22 years were analyzed. The results showed the sensitivity and specificity for stage H to be 0.74 and 0.84 for males and 0.73 and 0.92 for females, respectively. The estimated post-test probability for males and females using stage H was 0.82 and 0.91. Hence, the level of accuracy obtained using Demirjian stage H as a cut off value for discriminating juvenile/adult status may not be sufficient by taking the second type (ethically unacceptable) errors into consideration.
Authors and Affiliations
R Sudha, Sudheer B Balla
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP368578
- DOI 10.5958/0974-0848.2017.00026.4
- Views 134
- Downloads 0
Fatal Paint Thinner Ingestion- A Case Report
Household poisons can cause serious damage to the health of children. Turpentine is a volatile hydrocarbon used in polishes, solvents, paints and textile industry. It is capable of causing serious toxicity, whether inges...
A Five year Retrospective study of Fatal Snakebite in Chandigarh Region
This is a 5 years retrospective analysis and demographic study of cases of fatal snake envenomation presenting to the mortuary of Government Medical College & Hospital, Chandigarh, from January 2011 to December 2015. The...
Pattern of Defence Injuries in Homicidal Deaths
Defence wounds are injuries which are suffered by an individual in an attempt to save oneself from assault or while defending oneself from the offenders. Based on the presence of such injuries it can be opined that the v...
Analysis of Profile of Hanging Deaths in Coastal Odisha
Hanging is one of the ten leading causes of death in the world, accounting more than a million deaths annually. In India, hanging is the second most common method of committing suicide, after poisoning. Hanging is a form...
Profile of victims of natural sexual offences in South Bangalore
Rape is a notoriously under-reported crime in India, because of its social stigma and the fact that in most of the cases, culprits are known to the victim. The examination of the survivors of alleged sexual offences is o...