Virtue Ethics in Search of a Decent Naturalism
Journal Title: Przegląd Tomistyczny - Year 2016, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
New possibilities of studying the activity of the human brain and new technologies of human enhancement have intensified the voices calling for more science in ethics. This often implies embracing a version of naturalism. The recent revival of virtue ethics seems to strengthen this trend and make it more promising. Joining together contemporary virtue ethics with naturalism, however, is highly problematic. In this paper, I reflect on several conditions for a happy coupling between virtue ethics and naturalism. In the first part, I mention Jonathan Haidt’s proposal as an example of such promising and problematic coupling; I focus on only one element that could undesirably weaken virtue ethics. In the second part, I indicate a way in which this element might be modified. This suggestion could also be beneficial to another general problem in contemporary naturalistic ethics, namely, its relation to religion. Scientifically-oriented authors love to denounce prejudices and presuppositions in what conservative ethicists say. These presuppositions are sometimes identified as religious. A scientific orientation, however, does not preclude anyone from other prejudices and presuppositions, including religious ones. I suggest that reading some religious texts might help in detecting such influences.
Authors and Affiliations
Piotr Lichacz
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP192041
- DOI -
- Views 84
- Downloads 0
T.J. White, The Incarnate Lord. A Thomistic Study in Christology , The Catholic University of America Press: Washington, D.C., 2015, 534 s.
Recenzja książki T.J. White, The Incarnate Lord. A Thomistic Study in Christology , The Catholic University of America Press: Washington, D.C., 2015, 534 s.
Metody matematyczne w badaniach z zakresu filozofii przyrody. Problem szybkości powstawania form w XIV-wiecznym traktacie "De sex inconvenientibus"
The anonymous treatise "De sex inconvenientibus" was written by an author who presumably belonged to the group of Oxford Calculators (it is assumed that he was William Heytesbury’s student). The four questions discussed...
Charakterystyczne rysy filozofii polityki Mieczysława A. Krąpca
Prof. Mieczysław A. Krąpiec (1921–2008) — one of the most eminent Polish philosophers, the main creator of the Lublin School of Philosophy. His conception of politics is presented in such publications as: ‘Toward a Human...
Die Verwendbarkeit der Dinge: Die Diskussion um das uti im 13. und frühen 14. Jahrhundert .
Plusieurs théologiens du XIIIe et du XIVe siècle discutent la question de savoir si toutes les choses créées peuvent être utilisées (c.-à-d. reliées à la fin ultime de la vie humaine). L’article analyse les positions d’A...
Jan Hus as a Philosopher: The Topic of Universals in Two Theological Contexts of His „Sentences” Commentary („Super IV Sententiarum” I, dist. 19 and 33)
After a brief summary of the literature on the topic of universals in Hus’s writings, the present study continues with a summation of our knowledge of Hus’s commentaries on Aristotle, and a presentation of those of Hus’s...