A Comparison of Charles Taylor and Talal Asad on the Issue of Secularity
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2012, Vol 2, Issue 4
Abstract
Talal Asad and Charles Taylor have been thinking and writing about secularism for at least one decade. Their works are widely read, discussed, and admired. They, by and large, constitute the contemporary framework of discussion for those interested in issues revolving around secularization, secularism, and the secular, which although are terms that refer to distinctive phenomena, are often misused as if they are either the same or simply aspects of the same process. However, these two scholars still hold significantly different, if not mutually contradictory, ideas about secularism. The aim of this article is not to provide a summary of their thoughts on secularism, but rather, to compare and contrast their critically different approaches to the issue of secularism. In this regard, this article argues that an unbridgeable gap exists between Asad’s and Taylor’s approaches to and engagements with the secular. This article first covers Taylor’s and then Asad’s approach and method through a close reading of Taylor’s A Secular Age, and Asad’s Genealogies of Religion, Formations of the Secular, and the edited volume on him, Powers of the Secular Modern.
Authors and Affiliations
Ayşe Polat
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP306296
- DOI 10.12658/human.society.2.4.R0005
- Views 79
- Downloads 0
The Development of Literature on Missionaries in the Turkish Language
This article surveys how Turkish writings on missionaries developed chronologically and contextually over the years. It focuses on publications over three periods in the history of modern Turkey beginning with publicatio...
“Bilim Devrimi” Kavramı ve Osmanlı Devleti
The emergence of modern science in science history is as important as the spread of it. In science history, the approach of ‘scientific revolution’ makes astronomy the trigometrical point and conceptualizes modernity fro...
Sokağı Büyülemek: Gündelik Hayatın Seküler Temelleri Üzerine Bir Soruşturma
Sekülerleşme süreci, pek çok disipline uzunca bir dönem tartışacak malzeme üretmiştir. Ne var ki sosyal bilimlerin ölçek daraltması, özellikle de gündelik hayat çalışmalarına yönelmesi için moderniteye karşı kayda değer...
Social Inclusion of Disabled People: Turkey, the United States, and Japan
People with disabilities face many barriers to participate in social life as normal people. Although there have been some improvements to remove these obstacles, they are inadequate. This study examine the social inclusi...
Muhafazakâr Sermayeye Sahip İşletmelerde Çalışan Uzman Meslek Sahibi Başörtülü Çalışanlar
Bu makalede, kamuda uygulanmakta olan başörtüsü yasağı bağlamında muhafazakâr sermayedarlar ve uzman meslek sahibi başörtülü çalışanlar ilişkisinin işveren çalışan boyutu araştırılmıştır. Çalışma; yazılı literatüre, çeşi...