A Comparison of Charles Taylor and Talal Asad on the Issue of Secularity
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2012, Vol 2, Issue 4
Abstract
Talal Asad and Charles Taylor have been thinking and writing about secularism for at least one decade. Their works are widely read, discussed, and admired. They, by and large, constitute the contemporary framework of discussion for those interested in issues revolving around secularization, secularism, and the secular, which although are terms that refer to distinctive phenomena, are often misused as if they are either the same or simply aspects of the same process. However, these two scholars still hold significantly different, if not mutually contradictory, ideas about secularism. The aim of this article is not to provide a summary of their thoughts on secularism, but rather, to compare and contrast their critically different approaches to the issue of secularism. In this regard, this article argues that an unbridgeable gap exists between Asad’s and Taylor’s approaches to and engagements with the secular. This article first covers Taylor’s and then Asad’s approach and method through a close reading of Taylor’s A Secular Age, and Asad’s Genealogies of Religion, Formations of the Secular, and the edited volume on him, Powers of the Secular Modern.
Authors and Affiliations
Ayşe Polat
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP306296
- DOI 10.12658/human.society.2.4.R0005
- Views 58
- Downloads 0
The Concept of Âh (Sigh) in the Ghazals of Nâbî
Nâbî, who is one of the most productive poet of classical Turkish literature, used the conception of âh (sigh) with its various meanings in his ghazals (Ottoman lyric poetry). This article aims to determine and classify...
“Avrupa’dan İçeri Avrupamerkezcilik”: Avrupamerkezciliğin Tezahürü Olarak İlerlemecilik ve On Sekizinci Yüzyıl Habsburg Monarşisi ve Rus Çarlığı Tarihyazımı
This article is an analysis of the progressive approaches often exhibited in the scholarship in the English language on the eighteenth century Habsburg Monarchy and Russian Tsardom. This article relates to the discussion...
“Liberal Otonomi” ve “Gelenek” Arasında Modern Üniversite Eğitimi
Bu makale bu iki farklı liberalizm yorumunun modern liberal değerlere rezervli gruplar ve düşünce gelenekleriyle nasıl ilişkiye geçtiğini ve bu grupların eğitimle ilgili taleplerini karşılamada ne kadar yeterli oldukları...
Mit Ghamr Savings Bank: A Role Model or an Irreplicable Utopia?
Despite Mit Ghamr Savings Bank being established in 1963 in Egypt and being commonly mentioned as the first example of Islamic banking in the world, it is yet to be analysed in depth. With the aim of filling this gap in...
Marx’s Justice? Tracing the “Ethical” in Marx’s Thought
This paper sets out to inquire into the ethical character of Marx’s objections to capitalism by revisiting the North American debate during the 1970s. Toward this end, it probes the theoretical implications of the recent...