A Portrait of the Historian of Religions: Joachim Wach and His Faith Seeking Understanding
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2015, Vol 5, Issue 10
Abstract
Joachim Wach (1898-1955), considered one of the founding fathers of the contemporary history of religions, has a multilayered personality: In order, he is a historian of religions who tries to demarcate the field’s boundaries and determine its methods, a phenomenologist of religion as he attempts to systematize the relationship between religion and society via typologies, and a faithful Christian who believes in the superior revealing of God in the person of Jesus Christ as well as a theologian who reflects upon how to approach nonChristian traditions. Within the scope of this paper, I will argue that Wach’s attempt to establish the history of religions as an autonomous, objective, and scientific discipline failed even in his own eyes as he is involved in the phenomenology of religion under the name of the “sociology of religion.” In addition, he acts as a quasitheologian when he is involved in the phenomenology of religion and when he provides us with comparisons and typologies. Moreover, although Wach seems to be a historian of religions who prioritizes methodology, he does not fit into either the field of the history of religions or theology.
Authors and Affiliations
Betül Avcı
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP315622
- DOI 10.12658/human.society.5.10.M0146
- Views 111
- Downloads 0
Bir Yahudi Karşı-Geleneği Olarak Yahudi Sekülerliği: Kökenleri ve Dinamikleri
Felsefi ve siyasi bir ideoloji olarak 19. yüzyıldan itibaren kullanılmaya başlayan sekülarizm terimi, günümüz itibariyle daha ziyade sosyolojik bir mana içermektedir. Sekülarizm ile bununla bağlantılı bir diğer terim ola...
Judging Islamism in a ‘Land’ Deprived of Fiqh: Islamism That Lost Its Memory Versus Indigenousness
Islamism, in all environment that it becomes a matter of debate, is considered as independent from relations with Islam/Muslims. This preferred approach, generally, is to ignore the epistemological relationship of Islami...
1953 Göçü Sonrası Yücelcilerin Memleket/Yugoslavya ve Ana Vatan/Türkiye Algıları
This study is a social memory project that deals with Yücelcis’ perceptions of Yugoslavia by viewing the social impacts of the Yücel Incident in Macedonian Turkish society as a movement, which emerged in socialist Yugosl...
Tarihsel Süreçte Bir Kentsel Değişim Örneği: Gedikpaşa
Gedikpaşa has received more than its fair share of the damage wrought by the industrialization policies that influenced Turkey in almost every field in the second half of the twentieth century. As a result, Gedikpaşa, kn...
Tarih ve Bilgi: Sahih Failliğin Yeniden Kazanımı İçin Bir Çıkış
It is a well-known fact that studies in philosophy and the social sciences in Turkey are mostly subjected to a western-centered way of producing knowledge as a result of the modernization process that has proceeded for n...