Analysis of the reliability of clinical examination in predicting traumatic cerebral lesions and skull fractures in patients with mild and moderate head trauma
Journal Title: Polish Journal of Surgery - Year 2013, Vol 85, Issue 12
Abstract
The aim of the study was to assess the reliability of neurological examination and other factors in predicting traumatic cerebral lesions and skull fractures in patients with mild and moderate head trauma (GCS 10-15). Material and methods. Over a one-year period, 227 patients: 145 male and 82 female, aged a mean of 51 years who sustained mild or moderate head trauma (GSC 10-15) were examined neurologically and had performed head CT scans. The neurological examination as a whole and each finding of the neurological examination were tested as predictors of the presence of traumatic abnormalities in the head CT scan. Results. Post-traumatic lesions in head CT scan were found in 109 patients (48%): skull fractures in 66 of these and brain injuries in 94; fifty-eight patients had skull fracture combined with brain injury. Seventeen patients required neurosurgical intervention (hematoma evacuation). Abnormal neurological examination showed the highest reliability in identifying patients with brain injuries in CT (sensitivity 87%, specificity 79%). Of single findings, gait abnormalities and consciousness disturbances, present in sober patients, were the strongest predictors of cerebral lesions. Likewise, abnormal neurological examination was the best indicator of skull fractures (sensitivity 77%, specificity 63%). Gait abnormalities and “racoon eyes” present in alcohol intoxicated patients were the strongest individual predictors of skull fractures. Conclusion. Results of our study show neurological abnormalities as the most reliable (although not 100% accurate) in identifying patients who are likely to have brain injuries and/or skull fracture following head trauma. Use of clinical decision rules may reduce the number of head CT scans performed “just in a case”.
Authors and Affiliations
Andrzej Żyluk, Agnieszka Mazur, Bernard Piotuch, Krzysztof Safranow
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP74291
- DOI 10.2478/pjs-2013-0107
- Views 137
- Downloads 0
Triple negative breast cancer with ACTH-dependent Cushing's syndrome - case report
Introduction: Endocrine and metabolic paraneoplastic syndromes in the course of malignant tumors result from ectopic production of hormones or hormone precursors in tumor cells. Production of hormones by endocrine tumors...
Clear Cell Carcinoma of the abdominal wall
Background: Clear cell carcinoma in scars after cesarean section is extremely rare, with only 22 cases reported in the literature. Management of this condition needs to be further explored. Here, we report of a patient w...
Degloving lower leg injury – the importance of additional treatment: negative pressure and hyperbaric oxygen therapy
Degloving injury poses a severe therapeutic challenge concerning both trauma and plastic surgery. The injury involves separation of skin and subcutaneous tissue from fascia and muscles. Treatment is often long-lasting an...
Consent for surgery in view of an ambigious court decision – case report
Guardianship courts seem to issue decisions in case of the need to obtain consent for surgery, amongst other things, when the patient is unable to consciously express written consent, and at the same time does not have a...
Powtórne operacje bariatryczne – wskazania i wstępna ocena powikłań pooperacyjnych
Otyłość, w chwili obecnej, stanowi bardzo duży problem zdrowotny na całym świecie. Najbardziej skutecznym leczeniem otyłości jest leczenie chirurgiczne. Wraz ze wzrostem liczby wykonywanych zabiegów bariatrycznych zwięks...