Berkeley on Certainty: A Dilemma
Journal Title: Ruch Filozoficzny - Year 2015, Vol 71, Issue 4
Abstract
In this paper it is argued that it is a condition sine qua non of the success of Berkeley’s anisceptic project that the concept of certainty (i.e. of infallibility, required in philosophy of his time and, according to Berkeley, plainly gained only by his immaterialist solution) have to be fully analysable in terms of his own philosophy, otherwise the very concept should be dismissed by him owing to its meaninglessness. I maintain that his philosophy makes two general ways of the analysis in question possible. I think, however, that both of them seem to have unexpected implications, especially in that it makes our empirical knowledge flowing from immediate perception become not absolutely certain. The alternative: meaninglessness of the term “certain” or uncertainty of that knowledge is what I call “a dilemma” here. Then I try to show that three additional ways of avoiding (or explaining) that dilemma, available assuming Berkeley’s philosophy, i.e. the ways which probably remain in accordance with his position, unfortunately fail as well.
Authors and Affiliations
Przemysław Spryszak
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP320487
- DOI 10.12775/RF.2015.010
- Views 61
- Downloads 0
„Nie ze mną trzeba być, lecz we mnie…” Problem samotności, indywidualizmu i wspólnoty w twórczości Adama Mickiewicza
Romantyzm jest tą epoką w rozwoju kultury europejskiej, która bardzo często uznawana jest za moment narodzin formy wielu problemów, idei i koncepcji, która dotrwała do czasów nam współczesnych. Bez wątpienia jednym z naj...
The Querist and the Development of George Berkeley’s Understanding of Society
The late editions of the Querist (1737–1750) appeared almost 40 years after George Berkeley published his Passive Obedience (1712) and almost 30 after An Essay Preventing the Ruin of Great Britain (1721), the first of hi...
Komunikat o działaniach Wrocławskiego Oddziału Polskiego Towarzystwa Filozoficznego Laudacja dr Katarzyny Kuczyńskiej na forum OW PTF Wrocław 03 II 2016
-
From The Querist to Siris and Back. Berkeley’s Social Philosophy 1737–1752
The article reconstructs a shift in Berkeley’s understanding of nature and human society in his late works: The Querist (1737-1752, various editions) and Siris (1744). Together with the abandonment of metaphysics of his...
Nakręcane światy. Twórczość Paolo Bacigalupiego w kontekście wybranych elementów kapitalistycznego systemu-świata
Paolo Bacigalupi jest uznanym autorem science-fiction. Jego powieści i opowiadania dowodzą, że jest autorem o wyjątkowej wrażliwości społecznej. Niniejszy artykuł przedstawia możliwą interpretację jego prac, analizując j...