Can Grade-6 students understand quarks? Probing acceptance of the subatomic structure of matter with 12-year-olds
Journal Title: European Journal of Science and Mathematics Education - Year 2015, Vol 3, Issue 4
Abstract
This study introduces a teaching concept based on the Standard Model of particle physics. It comprises two consecutive chapters – elementary particles and fundamental interactions. The rationale of this concept is that the fundamental principles of particle physics can run as the golden thread through the whole physics curriculum. The design process was conducted from a constructivist perspective based on students’ documented conceptions. Three pillars underpin the whole teaching concept: a permanent model character, linguistic accuracy, and innovative typographic illustrations. Using the framework of design-based research, microteaching sessions with 20 Grade-6 students were conducted to probe its acceptance. The study focusses on learning processes of 12-year-olds with respect to elementary particles. Our findings indicate broad acceptance of most key ideas, but also avoidance when considering the permanent model character of physics. The most promising outcomes of the study are pure typographic illustrations. Not only were these thoroughly accepted by all students, but they also seem to reduce known misconceptions. Overall, students’ understanding of elementary particles improved fundamentally.
Authors and Affiliations
Gerfried J. Wiener| CERN, European Organization for Nuclear Research, Geneva, Switzerland, University of Vienna, Austrian Educational Competence Centre Physics, For correspondence: gerfried.wiener@cern.ch, Sascha M. Schmeling| CERN, European Organization for Nuclear Research, Geneva, Switzerland, Martin Hopf| University of Vienna, Austrian Educational Competence Centre Physics
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP8073
- DOI -
- Views 344
- Downloads 26
Deepening prospective mathematics teachers’ diagnostic judgments: Interplay of videos, focus questions, and didactic categories
This study aims to describe how energy subject is taught in 9th grades. The study is designed as a descriptive case study with the participation of 3 physics teachers and 85 students. Data were obtained through observati...
Definitions are important: the case of linear algebra
In this paper we describe an experiment in a linear algebra course. The aim of the experiment was to promote the students' understanding of the studied concepts focusing on their definitions. It seems to be a given that...
Fostering modeling competencies: benefits of worked examples, problems to be solved, and fading procedures
The application of mathematics to real-world problems is moving more and more in the focus of attention of mathematics education; however, many learners experience huge difficulties in relating “pure” mathematics to ever...
Fallacious argumentation in student reasoning: Are there benefits?
This article reports on an analysis of episodes of invalid or controversial arguments that occurred while two different groups of students worked on similar fraction tasks and examine the role that these types of argumen...
Enhancing laos students’ understanding of nature of science in physics learning about atom for peace
This paper aimed to study of Grade 12 students’ understanding of nature of science in learning about atom for peace through science technology and society (STS) approach. Participants were 51 Grade 12 who study in Thongp...