CRITICAL REVIEW OF A META-ANALYSIS FOR THE EFFECT OF SINGLE AND MULTIPLE SETS OF RESISTANCE TRAINING ON STRENGTH GAINS
Journal Title: Medicina Sportiva - Year 2012, Vol 16, Issue 3
Abstract
A meta-analysis is a controversial statistical procedure that combines the data from several independent studies in an attempt to produce an estimate for the effectiveness of a specific intervention. The validity of a meta-analysis, also known by its critics as numerological abracadabra, is dependent on the arbitrarily defined criteria and discrimination of the analyst, and more importantly, on the quality of the inclusive studies. The focus of this commentary is a meta-analysis by Krieger, who claimed that multiple sets of each exercise are superior to a single set of each exercise for increasing muscular strength. Some examples of the inclusive studies that he awarded the highest quality scores are shown in this Critical Review to be very poor quality studies and not acceptable for inclusion in a meta-analysis.
Authors and Affiliations
Ralph Carpinelli
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP74192
- DOI 10.5604/17342260.1011393
- Views 63
- Downloads 0
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN STAR EXCURSION BALANCE TEST AND LOWER EXTREMITY STRENGTH, RANGE OF MOTION AND ANTHROPOMETRIC CHARACTERISTICS
Objective: To consider the relationship between hip muscles strength, anthropometric characteristics and range of mo¬tion (ROM) with Star Excursion Balance Test (SEBT), a test of dynamic postural control. Methods: Forty...
A COMPARISON OF METHODS TO DETERMINE VENTILATORY EFFICIENCY IN ATHLETES
Introduction: Human ventilatory efficiency is quantified during exercise using the slope of the linear relationship between minute ventilation (¦E) and carbon dioxide output (¦CO2), and the oxygen uptake efficiency slope...
EFFECT OF CAFFEINE ON FATIGUE DURING SUBMAXIMAL ISOMETRIC CONTRACTIONS AT DIFFERENT KNEE ANGLES
Introduction: In the knee extensors, the time to fatigue for intermittent isometric contractions can be increased by caffeine. Fatigue is muscle length dependent. Objective: We examined the effect of caffeine on fatigue...
FIVE YEAR EXPERIENCE WITH THE UPGRADED DYNAMIC FLIGHT SIMULATOR (HUMAN CENTRIFUGE) FOR EUROFIGHTER /TYPHOON PILOT TRAINING IN THE GERMAN AIR FORCE
Introduction: Fighter Pilots of the German Air Force (GAF) are trained in a modern human centrifuge. The goal of the training is to familiarise them with high acceleration forces (G-Force) and with new Anti-G suits.Obje...
EXERCISE COUNTERMEASURE TO WEIGHTLESSNESS DURING MANNED SPACEFLIGHT
The purpose of this Brief Commentary is to review some of the problems inherent in past and current exercise machines that were designed as attempted countermeasures to weightlessness during manned spaceflight. A counter...