Do we need a new classification of parotid gland surgery?
Journal Title: Otolaryngologia Polska - Year 2016, Vol 70, Issue 3
Abstract
Background: In February 2016 the European Salivary Gland Society (ESGS) presented and recommended classification of parotidectomies based on the anatomical I-V level division of parotid gland. The main goal of this paper is to present the new classification, and to answer the question if it is more precise compared to classic one. Material and method: 607 patients (315 man, 292 women) operated on for parotid tumours in a tertiary referral centre, Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Medical University of Poznań (502 benign and 105 malignant tumours). Parotid surgery descriptions provided by retrospective analysis of all operating protocols covering the years 2006-2015 were “translated” into the new classification proposed by the ESGS.Results: Analysis of operating protocols and fitting them into the new classification proposed by the ESGS show some discrepancies, in both benign and malignant tumours. Based on the re-evaluation of 607 cases, in 94 procedures for benign tumors the only information available was that surgery was performed within the superficial lobe. Thus, the new classification forces the surgeon to be much more precise than previously. In 3 cases the whole superficial lobe was removed, together with the upper part of the deep lobe. Because the classification lacked parotidectomy I–II–IV, it indicated that the new classification was insufficient in the aforementioned three cases. In 6 cases of ECD more than one parotid gland tumour was removed. Among malignant tumours, total parotidectomy was the predominant procedure. In 3/13 cases of expanded parotidectomy the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) was additionally removed and it seems that the acronym TMJ should be included among the additional resected structures. It is also necessary to supplement the description of the treatment with casuistically resected anatomical structures for oncological purposes (RT planning) and follow-up imaging. Currently, since 2015 in Poland there has been the National Cancer Registry of benign salivary gland tumours (https://guzyslinianek.pcss.pl). New surgical anatomy and classification based on it will be very helpful in unequivocal, albeit brief and not laborious, reporting of procedures.To summarize, the classification is: easy to use, precise, and forced the surgeon to make a detailed description saving time at the same time. Although it is broad and accurate, it did not cover all clinically rare cases, multiple foci and it does not contain key information about the rupture of the tumour’s capsule, so it is necessary to complement the type of surgery by this annotations. The simple, clear and comprehensive classification is especially valuable for centres that lead registration. Thus, we are personally grateful for this new classification, which facilitates multicentre communication.
Authors and Affiliations
Małgorzata Wierzbicka, Krzysztof Piwowarczyk, Hanna Nogala, Marzena Błaszczyńska, Michał Kosiedrowski, Cezary Mazurek
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP76750
- DOI 10.5604/00306657.1202390
- Views 83
- Downloads 0
The significance of Karol Gilewski (1832–1871) for the Polish laryngology
The professional and scientific activities of Karol Gilewski (1832-1871), one of the famous Cracovian physicians, the professor of the Jagellonian University are described first of all. His treatise on laryngofissure and...
The cytokines at maxillary sinuses washings as inflammatory process expression
Introduction. In a pathogenetic chain of chronic sinusitis there is a set of cellular and humoral factors that are accepted as characteristic of a chronic inflammatory process. These include mast cells, granulocytes (bas...
Assessment of acoustic characteristics of voice in patients after injection laryngoplasty with hyaluronan
Background: Glottal incompetence is one of the most common contributing factors in patients who suffer from dysphonia. One of the different treatment approaches is injection laryngoplasty. The aim of the study was to ass...
Analiza oceny histopatologicznej zmian patologicznych usuniętych w endoskopowych operacjach nosa i zatok przynosowych w materiale własnym
SUMMARY Introduction: The work aimed at evaluating results of histopathological examination of postoperative material in endoscopic paranasal sinus surgery in the own material. Materia! and methods: The analysis covered...
Franciszek Leopold Lafontaine (1756-1812) and his work on catarrh
The professional and scientifi c activities of Leopold Lafontaine (1756-1812), an eminent military surgeon, the chief army surgeon in the Grand Duchy of Warsaw are presented in full particular. He was a editor-in-chief a...