‘Engaging in an argumentative discourse’- narratives from biology classrooms
Journal Title: European Journal of Science and Mathematics Education - Year 2015, Vol 3, Issue 1
Abstract
The present paper delves into the classroom dynamics of Biology classrooms taking into account teaching learning processes associated with some of the ethical issues in Biological Sciences. Argumentation and debate appear to be the major transactional approaches adopted by teachers for dealing with these issues. The classroom discourses emanating from teacher student conversations have been analysed on four planes, viz., ethical, social context, interactional context and personal agency of the teacher. Toulmin’s method of argument analysis has been used in order to analyse the level of arguments of both teachers and their students. The findings reveal significant differences on all the four planes at K?12 and Undergraduate levels and, have implications for building upon teachers’ pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) with respect to ethical issues.
Authors and Affiliations
Astha Saxena| Department of Education, University of Delhi, New Delhi, India, For Correspondence: saxena.astha2010@gmail.com, Alka Behari| Department of Education, University of Delhi, New Delhi, India
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP8051
- DOI -
- Views 407
- Downloads 27
Minimal interventions in the teaching of mathematics
This paper addresses ways in which mathematics pedagogy can benefit from insights gleaned from counselling. Person-centred counselling stresses the value of genuineness, warm empathetic listening and minimal intervention...
Investigative homework with apples: An opportunity for primaryschool students to learn actively the relationship between density and flotation
This paper describes investigative homework with apples, aiming to contribute to the primary?school students? understanding of density and conditions leading to floating and sinking. The assignment represents an opportun...
Introducing new material for a standardized exam: a controlled, prospective, double-blinded test of student learning
Do multiple choice unit tests reflect what students have learned during the unit? The day before the administration of a county?mandated multiple choice test, two classes were shown a topic they had not previously seen,...
Developing a pedagogical model for a massive open online course (MOOC)
MOOCs are a new phenomenon in higher education and have the potential to change both student behaviour and design of courses. However, at present MOOCs are still in the experimental stage and it won’t be clear for some t...
A workshop for high school students on naive set theory
In this article we present the prototype of a workshop on naive set theory designed for high school students in or around the seventh year of primary education. Our concept is based on two events which the author organiz...