Estimative conceptions in the activities of cassation administrative court for determining admissibility of judicial decisions, where the case constitutes a significant public interest or paramount importance for the plaintiff
Journal Title: Вісник Запорізького національного університету. Юридичні науки - Year 2018, Vol 4, Issue
Abstract
The paper outlines the process for implementing procedural discretion by the court of cassation instance in the use of estimative conceptions regarding the admissibility of appeals against court decisions, if the case is of significant public interest or of exceptional importance to the plaintiff. The author has proposed the feasibility of using models of “greedy” local search algorithms and/or the dynamic programming framework to establish “appropriate” criteria for opening or refusal to open cassation proceedings. It has been proved that the court’s assessment of such grounds is possible both under the condition of “positive” and “negative” regulation, in case of obscure content of legal provisions. Procedural discretion has been specified as legitimate in response to simultaneous behavioural patterns, being regulated by procedural law. It is about legitimizing the procedural behaviour of the court and the participants in the case, taking into account the purpose of the law (teleological interpretation) and the relationship between the arguments from the context of the case in accordance with the principle of justice. Attention has been focused on the formulation of approaches of the cassation administrative court on the admissibility of cassation appeal of court decisions. The author has substantiated that in fact a “three-step test” is used to establish a significant public interest or the exceptional value of the case for the complainant, i.e. 1) according to the legitimate goal; 2) on the basis of requirements regarding the quality of law (accessibility, predictability, clear definition of the boundaries of discretionary powers) based on the assessment of the circumstances of the case and statutory regulation; 3) taking into account the principles of proportionality, “the need for a democratic society” in the formulation of the operative part of the court decision.
Authors and Affiliations
А. А. Барікова
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP663042
- DOI -
- Views 65
- Downloads 0
OMBUDSMAN IN THE MECHANISM OF HUMAN RIGHTS PROTECTION IN UKRAINE: SEARCH FOR AN EFFECTIVE MODEL IN THE CONTEXT OF FOREIGN EXPERIENCE ADOPTION
The article studies the legal nature of ombudsman as an important institute of human rights which is intended to contribute to the protection of human and civil rights. The research is based on the analysis of basic mode...
АДМІНІСТРАТИВНО-ПРАВОВЕ РЕГУЛЮВАННЯ ЗДІЙСНЕННЯ ВІЙСЬКОВОСЛУЖБОВЦЯМИ ЗБРОЙНИХ СИЛ УКРАЇНИ СВОГО КОНСТИТУЦІЙНОГО ПРАВА НА ВІДМОВУ ВІД ВИКОНАННЯ ЯВНО ЗЛОЧИННОГО НАКАЗУ
У статті досліджуються організаційно-правові й адміністративно-процедурні засади здійснення військовослужбовцями Збройних Сил України свого конституційного права на відмову від виконання явно злочинного наказу та можливі...
ARE CONSUMER RIGHTS SECURED ALONG WITH THE ENFORCEMENT OF A SPECIAL LAW “ON CONSUMER LENDING”?
With the enactment of the Law of Ukraine “On Consumer Lending,” new applications were introduced for its putting into operation and counteracting abuses, now for the concession by commercial banks of rights for consume...
ПРАВО НА ЖИТЛО ТА ЦИВІЛЬНО-ПРАВОВИЙ ЗАХИСТ ЖИТЛОВИХ ПРАВ: ЦИВІЛЬНО-ПРАВОВИЙ АНАЛІЗ
Стаття присвячена комплексному дослідженню змісту права громадянина на житло (як особистого немайнового, так і майнового) й особливостей його цивільно-правового захисту. Автор відділяє право на житло від суміжного права...
SOME METHODS OF HANDWRITTEN RECORDS IDENTIFICATION
The article considers problematic issues that arise under dangerous influence, which is inherent in selective concentration of the thinking of a graphologist during investigation and under the influence of different fact...