FACT FINDING, WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE & REASONABLE DOUBT IN CIVIL & CRIMINAL TRIALS
Journal Title: International Journal of Political Science, Law and International Relations (IJPSLIR) - Year 2017, Vol 7, Issue 1
Abstract
“It is known maxim of law that it is better to acquit a guilty person than punish an innocent one”. How does law support and help to achieve this maxim is to be examined through civil and criminal trials’ procedures and announcement of judgments by the courts. To give a final verdict any trial has to find the facts of the case and then apply Law to the same. But facts may have other circumstances that can drastically change the potential reasons for that fact to take place. To sieve through the facts and reasons Law demands from litigants to present the evidence (documentary or witnesses) to the judge. Objective justice can only be achieved when a court system admits only most relevant and trustworthy evidence. The burden of producing evidence is on party what they allege or deny. But Guilt or innocence needs to be established without any doubt to fully practice the maxim quoted above. This article seeks to examine the burden to bring evidence placed on parties in adversarial and inquisitorial legal systems and concept of “reasonable doubt” in the evidences which can change the course of a trial and hence bring unexpected judgment. The article also seeks to highlight common factors in Islamic Law and common law principles regarding proof and reasonable doubt.
Authors and Affiliations
MISBAH SABOOHI
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP222192
- DOI -
- Views 110
- Downloads 0
Is there a Future for Verification and Conclusive Evidence (‘VCE’) Clauses in Australian Banking Contracts?
In certain jurisdictions, Verification and Conclusive Evidence (‘VCE’) clauses operate successfully in banking contracts in order to protect the interests of banks in their dealings with their customers. The VCE clause h...
The Bar on Women to Enter Places of Worship: A Violation of Fundamental Rights
“Unity in Diversity hasn’t been depicted in the different religions of India with the one possible exception of discrimination towards women, be it Islam, Hinduism or Christianity.” Bias in the eyes of Gods towards the g...
China’s Strategic Choice: Opportunities and Challenges
South Asian region is quite unique as it is inhabited by two nuclear powers hostile to each other and one of the emerging economies of the world. During Cold War, the strategic scenario in South Asia was pentagonal. The...
Honour Killing in India
Caught in the middle of an ancient culture dating back several millenniums juxtaposed with modernization and globalization, India has witnessed a paradigm shift in social values and principles. International media has co...
Assessment of the Role of Egypt’s 2015 Parliament in Promoting Democracy and Good Governance
Democracy and good governance are no longer a luxury; however, they are essential for sustainable development. Parliaments are the imperative foundations of democracy and good governance. Authorities and functions of par...