Hadith, Maskh (Metamorphosis), and Cultural Context: A Study of a Ṣaḥīḥayn Report on the Transformation of Jews into Mice
Journal Title: Ankara Üniversitesi İlahiyat Fakültesi Dergisi - Year 2018, Vol 59, Issue 2
Abstract
This article deals with a hadith report about a Jewish community metamorphosed and turned into mice in ancient times, and aims at contributing to studies as to how to evaluate religious texts by taking into consideration the cultural context in which they came into being. Firstly, I attempt to make an assesment of the report both from the point of the classical hadith literature and the cultural/environmental codes of the early period. Then I examine the place of maskh (metamorphosis), as a universal belief and a mode of imagination, in the Islamic thought and describe the cultural atmosphere surrounding the report in question. I also touch upon the criticisms directed against and the comments on this report that has a rather odd yet fascinating content. The positive and negative discourses developed concerning the subject makes one think that there might be a dialogue problem between researchers and the hadith literature. For this reason, I suggest a reevaluation of the approaches towards hadith and its literature, and, in this regard, I offer a way of reading the narratives which were not part and parcel of the apostolic duty of the Prophet and which reflected the socio-cultural beliefs and assents of the time from a wider and more comprehensive perspective and as an original segment of the long human history.
Authors and Affiliations
Suat Koca
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP602667
- DOI 10.1501/Ilhfak_0000001498
- Views 87
- Downloads 0
From Consultation to Solidarity: Shūrā as an Activation Code of Individual and Social Potentials
Potentials Shūrā amounts to consulting someone else’s knowledge and experience in situations where it becomes challenging to find a solution to problems. It appears to be an active power in achieving “the right knowledge...
Hadith, Maskh (Metamorphosis), and Cultural Context: A Study of a Ṣaḥīḥayn Report on the Transformation of Jews into Mice
This article deals with a hadith report about a Jewish community metamorphosed and turned into mice in ancient times, and aims at contributing to studies as to how to evaluate religious texts by taking into consideration...
Shīʿī Scholar Hāshim Maʿrūf al-Ḥasanī’s Use of Textual Criticism in Identifying
Fabricated Traditions One of the most significant Shīʿī authors of the 20th century in Lebanon, Hāshim Maʿrūf alḤasanī is known for his critical approach towards Shīʿa thought. Al-Mawḍūʿāt, one of his masterworks, enable...
When “Civil Religion” Becomes “Political Reli- gion”: The Special Case of Great Britain
Recently there has been a renewed interest in the study of ‘civil religion’ from a comparative perspective. Some literature developed around the concept tends to present civil religion as a universally applicable theory....
THE STORY OF A POEM THAT SENT ITS POET TO EXILE
In 1926, following the assassination attempt on Atatürk, Mehmed Kemaleddin Kharputi (1867-1936), mufti of Elazığ, was subjected to a trial, dismissed from his official post (mufti) and exiled to Samsun. He was convicted...