Happy is the Land that Needs No Heroes
Journal Title: Anglica. An International Journal of English Studies - Year 2018, Vol 27, Issue 3
Abstract
This essay interrogates two articles by the Canadian historian Jeff Keshen and the Australian historian Mark Sheftall, which assert that the representations of soldiers in the First World War (Anzacs in Australia, members of the Canadian Expeditionary Forces, the CEF), are comparable. I argue, however, that in reaching their conclusions, these historians have either overlooked or insufficiently considered a number of crucial factors, such as the influence the Australian historian/war correspondent C. E. W. Bean had on the reception of Anzacs, whom he venerated and turned into larger-than-life men who liked fighting and were good at it; the significance of the “convict stain” in Australia; and the omission of women writers’ contributions to the “getting of nationhood” in each country. It further addresses why Canadians have not embraced Vimy (a military victory) as their defining moment in the same way as Australians celebrate the landing at Anzac Cove (a military disaster), from which they continue to derive their sense of national identity. In essence, this essay advances that differences between the two nations’ representations of soldiers far outweigh any similarities.
Authors and Affiliations
Donna Coates
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP448236
- DOI 10.7311/0860-5734.27.3.06
- Views 9
- Downloads 0
Like Mother, Like Daughter?: Matrilineal Opposition in African American Mulatta Melodrama
The article juxtaposes representations of mothers and daughters in selected African American novels that feature near-white female protagonists: W. W. Brown’s Clotel, Or the President’s Daughter (1853), Frances E. W. Har...
Why and How Should We ‘Remember’ the Great War?
Introduction
No Fear Shakespeare?
Introduction article on Shakespeare's plays and theatrics and their surprising, sometimes awry, meaningful adaptability to changing historical times.
Happy is the Land that Needs No Heroes
This essay interrogates two articles by the Canadian historian Jeff Keshen and the Australian historian Mark Sheftall, which assert that the representations of soldiers in the First World War (Anzacs in Australia, member...
Literature, Politics and the CIA: Polish-English Literary Translation at the Time of the Cold War
The paper examines the interdependence of literature and world politics, focusing on contemporary Polish prose, mainly in English translation, promoted in the West between 1945 and 1989 for its anti-communist message, no...