Importance and usefulness of separate opinion exposed on giving judgment
Journal Title: Revista Institutului Național al Justiției - Year 2016, Vol 38, Issue 3
Abstract
In this article, making a synthesis of judicial practice based on documentary material accumulated through my professional activity, we wanted to open a scientific discussion on the importance and usefulness of separate opinion exposed on giving judgment, considering that this institution of Criminal Procedural Law is an essential element in ensuring and promoting the independence of the judge in deliberations. The approach to the problem is flagged as relevant to realism, balance and importance of separate opinion on the fair settlement of the case, the aim being legal challenge and stimulate research of this topic for the benefit of jurisprudence and legislation. From this perspective, we suggest for reading and analysis considerations of an separate opinion in a decision of the court of appeal in a criminal case recently held. We also propose the modification of the content of Article 340, para. (3) of Criminal Procedural Code in the following formula: „If the decision is taken by the majority, the separate opinion of judge is attached and this will be mentioned in the enacting part of de decision”.
Authors and Affiliations
Sergiu Furdui
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP195302
- DOI -
- Views 122
- Downloads 0
Anti-corruption expertise of the Criminal Code of Ukraine: specific aspects
Existence of the corruptibility/corruption in the text of Criminal Code of Ukraine does not yet means that the person which applies the law will use this gap. However, such possibility may occur. In this regard, is very...
Constitutional guarantee on pension rights
European Court of Human Rights when interpreting the art.1 from the Protocol 1 is constantly enlarging its field of application, modifying a classical vision of the goods and property. In this context, the pension right...
The legal basis of interaction in the criminal investigation
This article presents a discussion on the legal bases of interaction regarding criminal matters investigation and prosecution. Article sets out legal bases for interaction statutory by law and departmental normative acts...
Artistic creations of magistrates: freedom of expression and the reserve obligation imposed on them
In this article the author aims to analyze, starting from a concrete case and reporting it to the ECtHR jurisprudence, the rights to private life and freedom of opinion and expression of magistrates, as well the limits t...
Introductory concepts of the name of international treaties in contemporary international law
The object of this research is the scientific approach to the name of international treaties. The incomplete content of the provisions of Article 2 of the Vienna Convention on the law of international treaties, and the v...