Internal and External Limits of the Principle of Consistent Interpretation of Domestic Law with the Directives of the European Union and Th eir Relevance for the Adjudication of the Administrative Courts
Journal Title: Białostockie Studia Prawnicze - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue 23
Abstract
Th is article examines the issues of external and internal limits of the consistent interpretation of the domestic law with the EU directives in the context of verifi cation adjudication of the administrative courts. Th e external limits of the pro-directive interpretation are derived from the EU law and the case-law of the Court of Justice of the EU. Th e limits of the pro-directive interpretation can as well be derived from the domestic law of the member states (the internal limits). Th is kind of limitations is strictly connected with domestic limits of the judicial interpretation. In the considerations it is argued that the pro-directive interpretation which goes beyond the literal meaning of domestic provisions could not be treated as being contrary to the domestic law. In the case-law of administrative courts the necessity of functional, purposive and axiological meaning of the contra legem limit is especially signifi cant. It is justifi ed to state that consistent interpretation must embrace operations of interpretation secundum legem and praeter legem. Therefore, the domestic contra legem limit is shaped and modifi ed by the EU rules of interpretation.
Authors and Affiliations
Marcin Kamiński
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP520916
- DOI 10.15290/bsp.2018.23.02.01
- Views 37
- Downloads 0
Kilka uwag o charakterze prawnym powództw w sprawach o ustalenie i zaprzeczenie pochodzenia dziecka oraz ustalenie bezskuteczności uznania ojcostwa
Polish lawyers are discussing the nature of the matters concerning the origin of the child (actions for establishing the motherhood or the fatherhood, actions for the denial of the motherhood or the fatherhood, action fo...
Justifi cation of Judgments of the Advocacy Disciplinary Tribunal
Th e subject of this article is jurisdiction of decisions of the Advocacy Disciplinary Tribunal. Th e author focuses on the independence of the Law on Advocates and the Criminal Practice Rules. Appropriate application of...
Sądowy dział spadku jako nabycie nieruchomości rolnej – wybrane aspekty praktyczne
Distribution of the estate by the court is a form of transferring the ownership of an agricultural property within the meaning of the Agricultural System Structuring Act of 11 April 2003. As a consequence, the court hear...
O konieczności poszerzenia zakresu kontroli zażaleniowej nad niektórymi decyzjami dotyczącymi praw oskarżonego – wybrane problemy implementacji unijnych dyrektyw w polskim procesie karnym
Th e Treaty of Lisbon from 13.12.2007, opened up new directions and methods for the harmonization of criminal procedures in EU Member States, implemented by using directives of the European Parliament and of the Council....
Situation of the Incapacitated in Granting Consent to Medical Treatment. Selected Issues
A basic right of each patient is the right to grant consent to medical treatment. A doctor cannot act without the knowledge and will of a patient. Contrary behaviour is treated as illegal. A possibility of using the righ...