Iranian Muslim Reformists and Contemporary Ethics: Revival of “Utilitarianism”
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2018, Vol 8, Issue 2
Abstract
This paper raises a moral issue for contemporary post-revolutionary Muslim intellectuals in Iran. According to traditional Islamic teachings, ethics enables people to transcend from this mundane world and offers guidance on ways to improve virtues. Most contemporary Iranian Muslim intellectuals have attempted to pave the way for accomplishing this goal. After clarifying the ways in which Iranian Muslim intellectuals have faith in virtue ethics as a best possible moral normative theory, we claim that virtue ethics fails to support some of our modern problems in the realm of politics such as human rights and democracy. Also, we argue that virtue ethics is not a good theory for ordinary average people who have weakness of will. A preliminary conclusion of the paper will be that utilitarianism, generally, and principle of utility, specifically, is a better solution to the modern problems. This, we believe, has been overlooked from the eyes of post-revolutionary Muslim intellectuals. Yet, we suggest that among different versions of utilitarianism, rule-utilitarianism is more justified to do this job.
Authors and Affiliations
Hossein Dabbagh, Soroush Dabbagh
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP318171
- DOI 10.12658/M0229
- Views 114
- Downloads 0
The Myth and Reality of Rukiye Hanim in the Context of Turkish Malay Relations (1864-1904)
The present article investigates the identity, partial biography, and relations of Rukiye Hanim. She is recognized as the grandmother of three significant families who have been playing distinguished roles in politics an...
Philosophy of Music in Mawlawi Thought: Love, Music, and the Nay in the Masnavi
Sama’ means to find Allah in one’s souls under the influence of music, to feel excitement, and to whirl like moths. This whirling is not done just by bodily movements. It should be performed with the entire soul, spirit,...
Komşuyu Anlamak/Anlatmak: 20. Yüzyılda Türkiye’de İran’a Dair Yayınlanan Kitaplara Dair Bir Değerlendirme
İran ve Türkiye, tarih boyunca dinî, siyasi, kültürel, edebî vb. açılardan etkileşim içinde bulunan iki ülke olagelmiştir. Kaşgarlı Mahmud asırlar önce, “Tatsız Türk bolmaz (Farssız Türk olmaz).” diyerek bu ilişkilerin d...
Religious Groups in the Face of Turkey Modernization
It is generally emphasized that there is a close relationship between modernization and secularization. Turkey’s modernization process can be regarded as a secularization process of religion, society and politics in rela...
“Bilim Devrimi” Kavramı ve Osmanlı Devleti
The emergence of modern science in science history is as important as the spread of it. In science history, the approach of ‘scientific revolution’ makes astronomy the trigometrical point and conceptualizes modernity fro...