LOGICAL ARGUMENTATION ON THE BASIS OF STATE EXAMINATION COMPOSITIONS
Journal Title: Problems of Education in the 21st Century - Year 2009, Vol 10, Issue 1
Abstract
The present article discusses students’ argumentative skills as reflected in state examination compositions. The study focuses on the question whether students can logically argue in state exam compositions. For the given purpose 1700 state examination compositions from the years 1997, 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2008 were analysed employing as methods T.A. van Dijk’s macrostructures and M.Hoey’s superstructures, the latter was related to the structure of the argumentative text type. The article discusses the logic of the argumentative text type: the correlation between the third paragraph and the logic of the paragraphs is analyzed, the comparison of the two most frequently used clusters deduced from the cluster analysis are presented with the respective examples of argumentation structures. The main problem of argumentation lies in the perception of the types of argumentation structures: as soon as multiple, coordinative or subordinative argumentation was employed in compositions, the logic of the argumentative structure suffered. During the learning process the specific characteristics of argumentation need to be explained in greater detail. Thus far the Estonian teaching materials have discussed single argumentation, however, mostly neglected the topic of text coherence.
Authors and Affiliations
Merle Kaldjärv
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP34610
- DOI -
- Views 406
- Downloads 0
MATHEMATICAL EDUCATION WITHIN BELARUSIAN INTEGRATED SYSTEM OF THE TYPE “COLLEGE – UNIVERSITY“
The article is about the modification of the main educational aim, which is urgent for Belarusian colleges nowadays: integration of general education, technical education and higher professional education. Diversity of s...
The AAlborg Model And pArTicipAnT direcTed leArning
Preparing students for a life as active citizens in a democratic society is one of the aims within the Bologna process. The Council of Europe has also stressed the importance of focus on democracy in Higher Education....
THE DEVELOPMENT OF SPEECH OF ESTONIAN CHILDREN AGED 2-3 YEARS AND IT`S RELATIONS WITH THE FACTORS OF THE HOME ENVIRONMENT
Language is a catalyst of cognitive change during early childhood. Identification and assessment are crucial in speech therapy, especially in early years. The aim of current research is focused in children between 2;0 a...
SECONDARY SCHOOL STUDENTS AND PHYSICS TASKS
The aim of this paper is to discuss the non-ttractivity of the solving of quantitative examples in Physics. The problem was fnd out not only in teaching and learning Physics at secondary and high schools, but also duri...
LEARNING TO BUILD AN INNOVATIVE WORK CULTURE AND WORKING ENVIRONMENTS
Working environments will suffer signifcant changes with the introduction of new technologies, materials and work processes. New designs for the working environment and a work culture supporting creativity and innovati...