MULTICULTURALISM: THE POLICY OF RECOGNITION OR REDISTRIBUTION?
Journal Title: Вісник Львівського університету - Year 2018, Vol 17, Issue
Abstract
This article analyzes the dilemma between the policy of recognition and redistribution within the philosophy of multiculturalism. The recognition policy relates to the status of inequality and identity problems, while the policy of redistribution is more linked to economical inequality and the role of the welfare state. The work of a Canadian philosopher Charles Taylor “The Politics of Recognition” was examined which defines the relationship between identity and recognition, which in turn leads to a policy of multiculturalism and recognition of “equal value of different cultures”. It is proved that the policy of recognition involves accepting and retaining differences in society. It is denied the main arguments of critics of multiculturalism within dilemma recognition – redistribution, which stated that the policy of multiculturalism focuses only on cultural inequality, and does not pay attention to the economical. The dualistic concept of justice by Nancy Fraser is analyzed as the opportunity to solve the dilemma of recognition – redistribution within multiculturalism. It is proved the lack of recognition or false recognition for Fraser does not mean mental deformation and does not impede ethical self-realization, as Honneth and Taylor believed. Instead, the non-recognition for Fraser is the institutional relationship of subordination.
Authors and Affiliations
Oksana Pidskalna
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP570721
- DOI -
- Views 70
- Downloads 0
GEOSTRATEGY OF THE MAIN RIVALS OF CHINESE GEOPOLITICS IN THE CENTRAL ASIAN REGION
The richest natural resources of Central Asia and military-strategic position are the geopolitical feature of the region and the cause of interest of the world powers here. Relations with the countries of the region have...
POLITICAL THOUGHT OF THE UKRAINIAN BAROQUE
The article explores and describes the peculiarities of studying the history of political thought in early modern Ukraine. The development of political thought in Ukraine at this time is under the influence of the tenden...
MAIN METHODS AND TECHNIQUES OF PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF AGGRESSIVE BEHAVIOR IN SOCIETY
In the article the essential characteristics of the phenomenon of aggressive behavior is established and analyzed its main determinants. Attention is paid to the need to find effective methods and techniques to prevent a...
AXIOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE NOTION “DEMOCRACY” AS THE COMMON IDEAL-OUTLOOK`S BASIC FOR CONSTRUCTING OF THE INTERCULTURAL POLITICAL DIALOGUE
The complex of characteristics of democracy as a tool of expanding of the humanistic values in the world scale is scrutinized. “Civilizational” matter of its ideal-ontological content, especially, in the light of juxtapo...
UNIVERSITY FACULTIES OF POLITICAL SCIENCE AS A CENTER FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE IN UKRAINE
The main organizational stages of the development of political science departments in higher educational institutions of Ukraine from the 90s of the twentieth century are revealed to the present. The work of profile depa...