MURSEL HADIS I STAV ZNANSTVENIKA O NJEGOVOJ VALIDNOSTI U ARGUMENTACIJI MURSAL HADITH AND SCIENTISTS’ ATTITUDES TOWARDS ITS VALIDITY IN ARGUMENTATION
Journal Title: Zbornik radova Islamskog pedagoškog fakulteta u Zenici / Proceedings of the Islamic Pedagogical Faculty in Zenica - Year 2012, Vol 10, Issue 10
Abstract
Different attitudes towards defining mursal hadith have been present since the second century of hijra and period of Ibn Qattan, up to the later hadith scholars, Ibn Abdu'l-Barra, Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani and others. There are also differences in regards to validity of argumentation of these kinds of hadiths. The purpose of this paper is to elucidate scholars’ attitudes on these issues by presenting various Shariah solutions as implications of those discrepancies. Since ‘irsal’ is a discontinuity of a chain of narrators (sanad), it becomes evident that the mursal hadith is a weak hadith. Certainly, the principle of presumption of innocence is not relevant for attesting the transmitter from the point of the science of hadith, because the transmitter that is ‘majhool’ (unknown narrator) is not acceptable until his faith and reliability is confirmed by an authoritative biographer or scholar of hadith of his time. On the other hand, ‘irsal’ is undoubtedly one of the least weaknesses in sanad of hadith. That is because the omitted transmitter belongs to the first generations of Islam which the Prophet (s.a.w.s) describes as best generations in the hadith: "The best of my nation is my generation then those who follow them and then those who follow them."
Authors and Affiliations
Salih Indžić
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP670446
- DOI -
- Views 100
- Downloads 0
OBRAZOVANJE I NACIONALNI IDENTITET BOŠNJAKA EDUCATION AND NATIONAL IDENTITY OF BOSNIAKS
The identification as a belonging of a person to the territory, people, culture, religion becomes one’s authentic property, identity. National identity includes territorial and ethnic type. The basic integrating element...
ISLAMSKI DOPRINOSI RJEŠENJU RASNOG PITANJA ISLAMIC CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE SOLUTION FOR RACIAL ISSUES
This paper treats the racial issue, which is present in an entire human history, and contributes to Islamic teachings overcoming and solving this issue. This important topic is present in the primary Islamic sources: the...
MUŠKO-ŽENSKI ODNOSI KROZ POSLOVICE U B/H/S I ENGLESKOM JEZIKU MALE-FEMALE RELATIONSHIP AS REPRESENTED IN PROVERBS IN B/C/S AND ENGLISH
The male-female relationship constitutes an eternal enigma analysed in different ways throughout the history. The status of women through the ages has been significantly different from the status of men; the domestic dom...
SOCIJALNI ASPEKTI POSLANIKOVOG, SALLALLAHU ALEJHI VE SELLEM, OPROSNOG GOVORA SOCIAL ASPECTS OF THE PROPHET’S, SAWS, FAREWELL SERMON
At the end of his Prophetic mission, the 10th year of hijrah, Allah's Prophet, Muhammad, saws, performed hajj. It was the only hajj performed by the noble Prophet, saws. Since he passed away returning to the Creator (“Il...
Neologizmi u govoru djece / Neologisms in children’s speech
The paper presents a case study – speech "errors", neologisms were recorded during the longitudinal monitoring of a child's speech, i.e. regular speech and language development from the third to the sixth year of life. T...