Na temat Drittwirkung w Niemczech. Odpowiedź na polemikę Bartosza Skwary
Journal Title: PRZEGLĄD SEJMOWY - Year 2018, Vol 148, Issue 5
Abstract
The article is a reply to polemic comments from Bartosz Skwara (“Sejm Review” 2017, no. 1) to my article Horyzontalne działanie praw podstawowych w Niemczech, [w:] Oddziaływanie współczesnych konstytucji na stosunki między podmiotami prywatnymi, red. M. Florczak-Wątor, Krakow 2015 [Horizontal effects of fundamental laws in Germany, in: The impact of modern constitutions on legal relationships between private entities, ed. M. Florczak-Wątor, Krakow 2015]. As stressed in the article and in accordance with the objective of the book, my interest lay in the analysis of applying the Drittwirkung concept in the constitutional jurisprudence of the FRG; it was not my goal to thoroughly discuss approaches to the issue of horizontality of human rights as presented in the German dogmatic theory. This stems from the fact that courts tribunals ultimately set the standard for the protection of rights of an individual, both in vertical and horizontal relations. The article presents arguments disproving the thesis proposed by the author of the polemic that in the FRG there dominates the direct version of Drittwirkung. It is unfound both as regards the German jurisprudence and the doctrine of law.
Authors and Affiliations
Iwona Wróblewska
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP456904
- DOI 10.31268/PS.2018.21
- Views 32
- Downloads 0
Sejm Ustawodawczy w historiografi i polskiego parlamentaryzmu
The article deals with issues from the sphere of research on the history of Polish parliamentarism in the interwar period and the position of the Legislative Sejm in the historiography of Polish parliamentarism. On the o...
Anatomia porażki wyborczej, red. Anna Pacześniak
The reviewed book pertains to the issue of changes which political parties undergo after an electoral defeat. The defeat is regarded is a critical organizational challenge, usually yielding divergent results. The discuss...
Kto traci a kto zyskuje na systemie podziału mandatów pomiędzy okręgi w wyborach do Parlamentu Europejskiego w Polsce
In Poland, the system of election to the European Parliament is based on a multistage procedure for the division of seats, which has departed from Polish traditional and well-established model of territorial representati...
Dyktatura parlamentarna w stanie wyjątkowym. Litewski Sejm w latach 1920–1927
The idea of summoning the Legislative Seimas arose at the beginning of Lithuania’s independence. In the years 1918–1919 Lithuania’s situation was very difficult. At the beginning of 1919, the government introduced martia...
W sprawie momentu wygaśnięcia mandatu posła, który w trakcie kadencji został mianowany na stanowisko ambasadora
The opinion refers to the moment of the expiry of a mandate of a Deputy nominated for the position of an ambassador during the term. The function of an ambassador is incompatible with the Deputy’s mandate on the basis of...