Orientalist Sources of Classical Sociology: A Comparative Analysis of Marx and Weber
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2011, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
Sociology emerged as a comparative science, which basically tries to find out the differences between societies. Hence, it is important to make comparisons with Oriental societies that may serve as a historical model and situate the forms of modern society with regard to them. In this process, sociology has provided new explanations for European societies through working on the information gathered by orientalists. Therefore, the development and transformation of orientalism have also led to the transformation of sociology. This transformation can clearly be seen through a comparative examination of the approaches, analysis, and sources of Marx and Weber, who supposed to represent opposite poles in sociology. In the mid-19th century while orientalism was at the developmental stage, Marx made broad generalization with limited analysis. When oriental studies became specialized and diverse in the early 20th century, Weber made more extensive comparisons supported by detailed analysis. Despite the epistemological and political differences between Marx and Weber, they were of the same mind in their interpretations of modern society through Oriental societies and their unquestioning use of orientalist sources.
Authors and Affiliations
Lütfi Sunar
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP305956
- DOI 10.12658/human.society.1.2.M0041
- Views 102
- Downloads 0
Modernite Tartışmalarına Alternatif Bir Yaklaşım: Modern Aklın Eleştirisi ve Geleneksel Düşünce
Bu makalede, modern dünyanın problemlerinin arka planı, modern paradigma ve geleneksel düşünce karşılaştırmasına gidilerek ele alınmaktadır. Bu yüzden modern aklın açmazları, aslen geleneksel düşüncenin bakış açısından i...
A Critical Review of Luhmann’s Social Systems Theory’s Perspective on Mass Media and Social Media
Niklas Luhmann’s theory of social systems relies on a biology-based self-reproduction process called autopoiesis. The process occurs within operationally closed systems. Luhmann constructs his theory through adapting thi...
Evil and Violence in the Context of Ethics, Politics and Democracy
In this article, we will discuss human nature and acts with regard to evil, violence, and democracy and whether they are inherent to our nature or not on ethics and political grounds. Then we follow the question which is...
Sino-Indian Strategic Rivalry in the Indian Ocean Region
This article aims to explicate Sino-Indian strategic rivalry for regional influence in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR). For this purpose, it focuses on actors’ actions, which can be interpreted as acts of strategic competi...
Kültür ve Medeniyet Bağlamında Batı Merkezci Eğitim ve Eleştirisi
For the last two centuries, “the West” has meant far more than a mere geographical area. Europe’s centrality has been emphasized in the production of culture, civilization, technology and scientific knowledge and has als...