Orientalist Sources of Classical Sociology: A Comparative Analysis of Marx and Weber
Journal Title: insan & toplum - Year 2011, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
Sociology emerged as a comparative science, which basically tries to find out the differences between societies. Hence, it is important to make comparisons with Oriental societies that may serve as a historical model and situate the forms of modern society with regard to them. In this process, sociology has provided new explanations for European societies through working on the information gathered by orientalists. Therefore, the development and transformation of orientalism have also led to the transformation of sociology. This transformation can clearly be seen through a comparative examination of the approaches, analysis, and sources of Marx and Weber, who supposed to represent opposite poles in sociology. In the mid-19th century while orientalism was at the developmental stage, Marx made broad generalization with limited analysis. When oriental studies became specialized and diverse in the early 20th century, Weber made more extensive comparisons supported by detailed analysis. Despite the epistemological and political differences between Marx and Weber, they were of the same mind in their interpretations of modern society through Oriental societies and their unquestioning use of orientalist sources.
Authors and Affiliations
Lütfi Sunar
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP305956
- DOI 10.12658/human.society.1.2.M0041
- Views 106
- Downloads 0
Two Axes Revolving Around the Discussions of Secularism in Turkey: Şerif Mardin and İsmail Kara
In Turkey, there have been ongoing discussions on the following issues: The role of religion in social life; the relevance of modernization activities, which the government endeavours to actualize through its institution...
Batı’da Sekülerlik ve Türkiye Müslümanlığının Seküler İçerimleri
Bu makale, Türkiye’de Müslümanlığın içerimlerini ortaya koymayı hedeflemektedir. Bilindiği gibi sekülerlik, Batı orijinli bir kavram olup, kendi doğal tarihi süreci içerisinde bir anlam ve zemin kazanmıştır. Bu süreçte H...
Pîr Ahmed Efendi, The Sheikh of Kalburcu, and Understanding of Alevîs in the Sample of Sofca
Pir Ahmed Efendi is an important person who lived in Kütahya at XVI. century and arrived scholars from line of his family as Müfti Dervis, Sunullâh-ı Gaybi. Pir Ahmed Efendi who had been respected at his period, has been...
Media Publicity of Civil Society Organizations in Turkey
This research explores media publicity of civil society organizations focusing on news published by the Turkish media. The data were obtained from 19 news portals, including dailies and Turkish news released by internati...
“Liberal Otonomi” ve “Gelenek” Arasında Modern Üniversite Eğitimi
Bu makale bu iki farklı liberalizm yorumunun modern liberal değerlere rezervli gruplar ve düşünce gelenekleriyle nasıl ilişkiye geçtiğini ve bu grupların eğitimle ilgili taleplerini karşılamada ne kadar yeterli oldukları...