Problem of informed consent to amputation in a female patient with gangrene of lower limbs – ethical aspects
Journal Title: Medycyna Ogólna i Nauki o Zdrowiu - Year 2012, Vol 18, Issue 3
Abstract
Lower limb ischemia is a clinical syndrome with a complex etiology. Critical ischaemia usually leads to rest pain in the extremities, it may also lead to a necrosis and gangrene. In the case of multi-level, scattered atheromatous changes in the arteries of the lower extremities with co-existing gangrene, amputation is an effective and life-saving treatment. In this report, the case of 70-year-old patient is described with type 2 diabetes, atherosclerosis, and critical lower limb ischemia, who was admitted to hospital with septic shock and extensive gangrene involving the foot and lower leg. Based on the advice of the surgeon, the patient was qualified for the amputation of both lower limbs at the thigh. Due to the severe general condition, the patient was treated in an intensive care unit. After stabilization of cardiovascular function, amputation of the lower limbs was proposed. The patient did not express her consent to such treatment, therefore, conservative treatment was applied. At the explicit request of the patient, she was discharged home after several weeks of hospitalization with progressive gangrene of both extremities. The presented clinical case was not only a medical challenge, but also a source of ethical dilemmas. In particular, attention should be paid to the discussion of problems related to the issue of informed consent, patient autonomy, respect for the right to self-determination, and assessment of competence to decide about own fate. Obtaining an informed consent is both a principle of medical deontology as well as a basis of the legality of a physician›s action. In order to consider a consent as conscious, it must be expressed voluntarily by a competent patient who has obtained the necessary information about own medical situation.Key words: lower limb gangrene, amputation, informed consent, autonomy, ethics, bioethics, deontology
Authors and Affiliations
Paweł Kiciński, Maciej Zakrzewski, Sylwia Przybylska-Kuć, Andrzej Prystupa, Jerzy Mosiewicz, Jakub Pawlikowski, Jarosław Sak
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP68884
- DOI -
- Views 126
- Downloads 0
The necessity of evaluation of prosthetic treatment of missing teeth caused by hard tissues of oral cavity diseases and injuries for students of Bialystok universities
[b]Introduction and objective. [/b]The main aim of the research was to estimate the need for prosthetic treatment among students of three Bialystok universities and to analyse the factors that may influence this need....
Concentrations of asbestos fibres at wild asbestos wastes damping grounds
Introduction. Products containing asbestos should be protected and removed according to precisely specified regulations.Asbestos products are removed by properly trained teams provided with suitable equipment. The above-...
Knowledge of women concerning breast cancer prevention in selected socio-demographic conditions
[b]Introduction. [/b]Breast cancer is one of the most common, among women, oncological diseases and constitutes a serious health and social problem in Poland. Knowledge of methods concerning its early detection, risk fac...
Reduction in intensity of pain and complications caused by preventive vaccinations in small children
Vaccination is a planned action which safeguards children against serious diseases; unfortunately, despite the fact that they are an enormous boon, alas they are painful. Therefore, the aim of this study is to provide m...
Effect of arterial hypertension on renal lesions in children with type 1 diabetes
Introduction. Arterial hypertension (AH), one of the complications of type 1 diabetes (T1DM) is a risk factor of the development of diabetic nephropathy.Objective. Evaluation of arterial hypertension in children with T1...