Projekt stanowiska Sejmu w sprawie o sygn. akt P 10/16
Journal Title: Zeszyty Prawnicze Biura Analiz Sejmowych - Year 2016, Vol 52, Issue 4
Abstract
In the presented project of a position, the author claims that indicated provisions of the Civil Code, in part which enabled acquisition of a land servitude of similar nature to a transmission servitude through usucaption, before articles 3051–3054 of the Civil Code entered into force, in situation when an administrative decision restricting rights of the owner of the land is non-compatible with provisions of the Constitution. Constitutional protection of the right of ownership requires every restriction of that right to fulfill certain obligations. From a constitutional standpoint, an institution of land servitude is a restriction of the right of ownership. In analyzed case the basis for the restriction provided in an act is of primary importance. The author does not agree with the Supreme Court that the analyzed provisions regulate land servitude. In her opinion, the provisions cannot serve as a basis for a land servitude as an autonomous right (a transmission servitude), and in consequence cannot serve as a basis for a restriction of constitutional right of ownership. According to the author, the analyzed regulation also does not fulfill the criterion of necessity.
Authors and Affiliations
Agnieszka Tomaszewska
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP311038
- DOI -
- Views 51
- Downloads 0
Opinia prawna dotycząca możliwości dochodzenia odszkodowania w sytuacji doznania przez dziecko niepożądanego odczynu poszczepiennego i powikłań poszczepiennych
The obligation to submit preventive vaccination is stipulated in provisions of the Act on Preventing and Combating Infections and Infectious Diseases among People. A producer of a vaccine may be liable for damage caused...
Opinia prawna na temat dopuszczalności pełnienia przez posła lub senatora funkcji ławnika
In Polish legislation there is no express prohibition that prevent a Deputy to the Sejm or Senator from holding the position of lay judge in a common court. You cannot say that the constitutional ban on the simultaneous...
Założenia zmian w regulacji prawnej w dziedzinie funkcjonowania Komisji ds. Unii Europejskiej – materiał analityczny
This paper deals with the regulation which specifies the rules in which the Sejm affects the policies of the European Union. It examines the assumptions for change in respect of the Act of 8 October 2010 on Cooperation o...
Ocena tematów zawartych w notatce informacyjnej Kancelarii Węgierskiego Zgromadzenia Narodowego z uwzględnieniem szans i zagrożeń dla Polski w procesie brexitu
The author presents an analysis of withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union (BREXIT) as well as expected solutions. Legal ways of withdrawal, negotiations, conditions of implementation of procedure set ou...
Opinia prawna na temat odpowiedzialności ministra za niewykonanie prawa Unii Europejskiej
Council and European Parliament regulations are legal acts which are directly applicable in the Polish legal order, what results in an require‑ ment of their application by all public authorities without issuing national...